TechSpot

Buying Decision: Western Digital vs. Seagate

By Psyched13
Jan 31, 2005
  1. Hello,

    I'd like to hear people's opinion on this. I'm buying a new drive to replace my dead IBM GXP 60GB (what a crap drive!!), and it will either be WD400BB 40GB or a Seagate ST380011A 80GB. They are both priced around the same so the Seagate appears to be better value.

    Seagate didn't have a great reputation in the '80s I hear. I'd be very interested in what some who has about 20 years of experience to give me an idea; what they were like in the old days, what they're like now.

    Thanks for your help,
    Psyched13.
     
  2. Nodsu

    Nodsu TS Rookie Posts: 9,431

    Any real life experience anyone may have applies to drives over a year old.
    Noone can tell how a new model will behave..

    Unless you can get much better warranty with WD go for the Seagate.
     
  3. Samstoned

    Samstoned TechSpot Paladin Posts: 2,582

    first 3 give same warranties at about the same price higher priced first
    Seagate would be my chioce first
    then Western digital
    maxtor for oem throw away
    IBM deskstar if you like to gamble
     
  4. Rick

    Rick TechSpot Staff Posts: 6,305   +52 Staff Member

    Based on my variety of experiences, I'd choose Seagate unless you are planning on dumping some money for WD Raptors.

    Experience from 20 years ago isn't going to help you, but Seagate's reputation took a dive after they bought Connor. :) Infact, the whole company took a dive with layoffs and being spread too thin overseas.

    But they've gained a large market share since and have remained very strong in company / business sales all the while. Their current consumer line of drives seem very reliable as the ratio of bad Seagate drives vs good ones seems lower than bad Western Digital vs. good ones. I don't have numbers, but that's just the way it looks after working on thousands of computers.

    My personal experiences with Seagate have been flawless. No problems. I cannot say the same for WD. But again, it is all subjective and luck of the draw...

    Also from my personal experiences, I might include Samsung if it is available at a low price as well.
     
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...


Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.