TechSpot

Former MPAA CTO speaks out against laws like SOPA

By Rick
Aug 14, 2012
Post New Reply
  1. Former Motion Picture Association's Chief Technology Officer Paul Brigner has offered a level-headed rundown regarding the perils of using DNS as a means of Internet enforcement. Once controversial legislation, SOPA relied upon DNS-blocking techniques to essentially take down undesirable websites -- a……

    Read more
     
  2. Wonder if there is a Hypocrite of the year award. Wow.
     
  3. Tanstar

    Tanstar TS Guru Posts: 410   +88

    He says what his current bosses want him to say, big deal. The only reason his opinion is being noticed now is because he changed sides in this war. Mercenaries do that.
     
  4. DanUK

    DanUK TS Booster Posts: 211   +9

    Maybe if he felt that strongly about it he should have resigned from MPAA instead of doing a U turn..
     
  5. ET3D

    ET3D TechSpot Paladin Posts: 1,180   +73

    You mean like maybe he should have resigned from the MPAA and gone to work for the Internet Society? :)

    I think that the Cory Doctorow article here makes him look better. To quote what Paul Brigner said:

    "My views have evolved over the last year as I engaged with leading technologists on DNSSEC. Through those discussions, I came to believe that legislating technological approaches to fight copyright violations threatens the architecture of the internet."
     
  6. ET3D

    ET3D TechSpot Paladin Posts: 1,180   +73

    Hmmm, that broke my post. I guess I shouldn't have tried to embed a URL. So here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2012/apr/17/why-mpaa-executive-joined-internet-society

    That's an article by Cory Doctorow which discusses the guy and how he switched sides, and makes him look better. To quote Paul Brigner from that article:

    "My views have evolved over the last year as I engaged with leading technologists on DNSSEC. Through those discussions, I came to believe that legislating technological approaches to fight copyright violations threatens the architecture of the internet."
     
    DanUK likes this.
  7. Jesse

    Jesse TS Evangelist Posts: 359   +42

    It didn't break your post, but I had the same issue just a moment ago. It appears to be a problem with the smilies. Upon refreshing, you will see that your post is there as you intended.

    FYI for Techspot devs.
     
  8. probably another case of not getting paid enough so time to bail out of the otherside.
     
  9. andy06shake

    andy06shake TS Guru Posts: 257   +21

    In a nut shell, they will never stop piracy, most ISPs here in the UK have banned TPB, now I have to click 3 times instead of 1 to access TPB. LoL LoL LoL! They have slipped, they have fallen and they cant get up. Leave the Internet alone NWO scum, you see its ours, your not getting it, so **** of and die in your DUMBs!
     
  10. Tygerstrike

    Tygerstrike TS Enthusiast Posts: 827   +93

    @Andy
    More to the point its not "yours" its theirs. The Internet is a system of interlaced servers. Unless you own a server that directly supports the function of the Internet, then you are just a user. Much like your TV set.
    You may not agree with what is being done to websites, but you do have to deal with it. If you feel that strongly about the "injustices" being commited then put you money where your attitude is. Run for some form of office that will give you a vote or say in what is done on the Internet. Atleast in your country. Your Lawmakers have deemed that TPB is not wanted. Use the tools that you as a citizen have. Start a PHYSICAL petition. Protest your views. Write letters and have the ppl you petition write letters to the Lawmakers.
    Otherwise, you simply sound like a young person dissatisfied.
    Remember youre not the only person who dissagreed with their govt. Back in the 70's and 80's it was all about music censorship. Many youth stated the same thing you did in your post. It takes hard work and persiverance to effect change. Not attitude on a website....
     
  11. andy06shake

    andy06shake TS Guru Posts: 257   +21

    "The Internet is a system of interlaced servers"

    Im aware of the how and why the internet in its current form originated

    "You may not agree with what is being done to websites, but you do have to deal with it"

    And deal with it we have and always will, we will win, they will lose simply because there are more of us than "Them" thats there greatest fear. Thats why they need to control the net. So "They" can control how we eat, sleep and ****, how we think essentially.

    "If you feel that strongly about the "injustices" being commited then put you money where your attitude is. Run for some form of office that will give you a vote or say in what is done on the Internet."

    No thanks politics is just not for me, im to honest for that game im afraid. Mass genocide and totalitarian control constructs just aint in my tool box.

    "Your Lawmakers have deemed that TPB is not wanted. Use the tools that you as a citizen have. Start a PHYSICAL petition. Protest your views. Write letters and have the ppl you petition write letters to the Lawmakers."

    **** there laws(excuse my french), I deem the " Lawmakers " unwanted, and will go out of my way to break as many of there nonsensical laws as I possibly can every day for as long as I draw breath!

    "Otherwise, you simply sound like a young person dissatisfied."

    Thank you very much I will take that for a complement since im in my early 30s

    "Remember youre not the only person who dissagreed with their govt. Back in the 70's and 80's it was all about music censorship. Many youth stated the same thing you did in your post."

    If I had the internet in the 80s I would have said my peace back then, guess now is the time eh?

    "It takes hard work and persiverance to effect change"

    Fair point but we have tried the carrot, now its time for the stick.

    3 simple rule's to follow, Take what you do not have, but have what you cannot take, never hurt anyone weeker than yourself. Life is simple that way. Just my opinion!
     
  12. Tygerstrike

    Tygerstrike TS Enthusiast Posts: 827   +93

    Sounds more like you just want to be a non conformist then do any of the real work to secure the internet. So that being said, have fun. You reap what you sow.
     
  13. andy06shake

    andy06shake TS Guru Posts: 257   +21

    So whats you claim to fame, what are you doing to secure the internet for the masses? Sounds like you have become a conformist. You are correct in the assumption, you do reap what you sow, and "They" have reaped and sowed so much crap all over not just the net but planet Earth also. Just because I have no interest in politics does not mean I have no interest in revolution! That being said, have a nice day Tygerstrike.
     
  14. TJGeezer

    TJGeezer TS Enthusiast Posts: 385   +10

    Gotta say my instincts take me in the same direction as andy06shake, though simple defiance won't change anything directly. Still, advice to work within a corrupt system to fix that system always make me suspect a *nix-type recursive joke. It takes disruption to change systems when the self-interest of those on top resists it, and systems aren't set up to encourage change.

    In the tech world, real change comes from disruptive technologies, which is why corporations buy politicians to set up legislated monopolies, restrict competition and attempt to keep markets free of change. That's what all the copyright and patent distortion is really about, so if a prominent member of the business world talks to technologists and changes his mind, kudos to him for being willing to listen and to rethink his position. And kudos to those like andy06shake who keep the pressure on.
     
  15. andy06shake

    andy06shake TS Guru Posts: 257   +21

     

Similar Topics

Add New Comment

You need to be a member to leave a comment. Join thousands of tech enthusiasts and participate.
TechSpot Account You may also...