TechSpot

Is a 200GB 4200 rpm internal hard drive bad?

By nikkiy21
Apr 10, 2007
  1. I've got a really good deal on a "scratched" Dell E1705 from the outlet site. It has a great spec but has a 200GB 4200 rpm hard drive. Is this really slow? Can I use an external hard drive if I want faster?

    Machine is to be mainly used for internet, music, photos, video (not video editing), word processing.

    Spec
    T7200 core 2 duo
    8X DVD/RW
    2048MB 667MHz ram
    200GB hard drive
    17" ultrasharp WUXGA screen
    256MB NVDIA Geforce Go 7900 GS graphics
    Vista home premium

    Thanks for any advice.
     
  2. SNGX1275

    SNGX1275 TS Forces Special Posts: 12,690   +337

    Yep, its going to be pretty slow (the drive, not anything else). Shouldn't be a problem for your list of things you'd use it for, but yes you could use an external.
     
  3. LNCPapa

    LNCPapa TS Special Forces Posts: 4,373   +289

    I second SN's comments - for your listed needs it will be fine and it's the only way to get 200g laptop drives atm.
     
  4. Tedster

    Tedster Techspot old timer..... Posts: 10,074   +13

    while it's ok for storage of movies, etc... it will run agonizingly slow. Don't use it for a primary drive.
     
  5. zipperman

    zipperman TS Rookie Posts: 1,423   +7

    4200 or 7200

    I doubt it's 4200 if it's 200 gb.Where did you get that description.
    I think it's possibly 5200 ( the norm before 7200 arrived,)
    but they whern't that large either.:wave:
    200 MB maybe.
    Whatever if it's not 7200,then it's ok as a 2nd storage drive,not for
    Windows OS install.
     
  6. Nodsu

    Nodsu TS Rookie Posts: 9,431

    No, it's 4200RPM.
     
  7. CraigMc

    CraigMc TS Rookie Posts: 50

    It's a notebook. Notebook HDD's run at 4200/5400. As LNCPapa mentioned previously ;)

    You can get 7200 SATA drives but not at 200Gb that I've seen.

    For what you intend to use it for and with 2Gb of RAM I doubt you'll notice the difference to be honest. It's only when you start moving or handling multiple large files that things really start to slow down. :)
     
  8. iss

    iss TechSpot Chancellor Posts: 2,896

    personally, I would get a 5400 rpm replacement drive for the notebook and a 2.5 USB enclosure to put the 200gb 4200 rpm drive in and use it for a external storage drive. but you would need the XP disk to reinstall the OS on the new drive.
     
  9. nikkiy21

    nikkiy21 TS Rookie Topic Starter Posts: 31

    Many thanks everyone for your replies. I'm going to see how I get on with the 200GB 4200rpm drive. Not familiar with external hard drives or USB drives - if I wanted a faster drive, what do I need exactly and what do I need to do to make it the primary drive? Can I actually change the drive within the laptop or is it better to use an external or USB drive and how do these work to be a primary drive??

    Many thanks in advance for your help.
     
  10. Tedster

    Tedster Techspot old timer..... Posts: 10,074   +13

    I had a 5200 in my laptop. Then I upgraded to a 7200. The 5200 was painfully slow. I can only imagine how slow a 4200 is. In any case I haven't seen 7200s in 200gb size.

    All you have to do, it get a faster drive and swap out with the current drive. Of course, clone your data onto the new drive before swapping. Some HD makers have kits with software to do this. The one I bought for my system did.
     
  11. zipperman

    zipperman TS Rookie Posts: 1,423   +7

    My experience

    I've been around since the first hard drives arrived , useing floppys first.
    It may be 4200,but i doubt it's 200 GB.20 Maybe.
    Like i said earlier,it's not suitable for an OS install.
    You don't need external,get an internal IDE 7200 and connect it as Primary Master.
    Then the other whatever it is,Make it a Primary Slave for storage.
     
     
  12. Nodsu

    Nodsu TS Rookie Posts: 9,431

    zipperman: maybe use the amazing power of the internet and see that 200GB 4200 RPM laptop drives are common?
     
  13. CraigMc

    CraigMc TS Rookie Posts: 50

    It is 200GB and it is SATA, putting in a 7200 IDE drive isn't an option in SATA laptops unfortunately (check out the dell site for the technical specs of the laptop in question).

    You should be able to get a 7200 SATA disk around 100GB in size which should be fine as a primary disk if you so wish, as mentioned by Tedster you would need to clone your current drive on to it, or, failing that perform a clean install on the new disk. This could work out as an expensive option though, 7200 SATA disks seems pretty hard to come by in 2.5" for laptops.

    You can buy 2.5" Drive Caddies that you can use to convert your 200GB 4200 disk into an external removable storage device then.

    With the 200Gb disk in the laptop being SATA instead of ATA it is perfectly suitable to install an O/S on. If it wasn't then manufactureres wouldn't supply there computers with them built in ;) 4200 SATA performs better than 4200 ATA over IDE
     
  14. zipperman

    zipperman TS Rookie Posts: 1,423   +7

    Post titles and first thread info

    I don't have a clue about laptops or i would not have replied.
    BY :wave:
    Laptops need a seperate Forum.
    Or at least entered in topic title.
     
  15. SNGX1275

    SNGX1275 TS Forces Special Posts: 12,690   +337

    They do, Mobile Computing but this was more specifically a HD (Storage & Networking) question. He also stated that it was for a laptop in his first post.
     
  16. LNCPapa

    LNCPapa TS Special Forces Posts: 4,373   +289

    Looks like as of yesterday we're all wrong - you can now get 5400 rpm 250GB drives and 7200 rpm 200GB drives in 2.5" size.
     
  17. CraigMc

    CraigMc TS Rookie Posts: 50

    Darn, how much are they retailing at? (they're SATA i assume?)
     
  18. zipperman

    zipperman TS Rookie Posts: 1,423   +7

    Where ?

    Dell E1705
    Am i supposed to know every model # by Dell ,or search for it.
    I don't think i should do what the poster should explain better.
    Sorry but i need a better description.
    HD and storage is quite different with laptops,so i don't reply if i know.
    But 200 GB is still hard to believe.
     
  19. SNGX1275

    SNGX1275 TS Forces Special Posts: 12,690   +337

    You are right zipperman, it wasn't explicitly stated. I had thought it was, but nonetheless there are a few clues in the specs. I don't want to hammer on you so don't take it that way, but this is what lead me to believe it was a laptop:

    8x DVD/RW is pretty slow, 16x or 18x is the standard for desktops.
    17" WUXGA is only a laptop screen, no desktops
    Geforce Go cards are only found in laptops
    and 4200 rpm drives don't exist in desktop models at 200 gigs.
     
  20. zipperman

    zipperman TS Rookie Posts: 1,423   +7

    Thanks for putting it nicely

    Sorry if i seemed Grumpy.Try this,
    See if you can update the Firmware.It improved mine.
     
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...


Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.