LukeDJ
Posts: 349 +111
This was a great review, very down to earth and helpful. I was actually considering buying a sound-card for myself, and I think this has convinced me it's worth it.
I do agree with some of the comments though, using a "rock" setting does somewhat discredit the review, as this puts an uncontrolled variable in the test that wouldn't be present in the majority of situations. I like the idea of drawing simple, down-to-earth conclusions from real-world situations, but this really does personalize the situation to a degree. Despite not being a major audiophile, I always turn the equalizer to flat before testing new speakers or headphones, and sometimes make small adjustments if I feel the speakers are lacking in a certain area. Judging by the comments, many others do similar.
Re-reading what I said, it seems like I'm calling the review completely irrelevant and useless, which isn't the case. I'm just saying that many of these people are somewhat justified in their criticism.
I do agree with some of the comments though, using a "rock" setting does somewhat discredit the review, as this puts an uncontrolled variable in the test that wouldn't be present in the majority of situations. I like the idea of drawing simple, down-to-earth conclusions from real-world situations, but this really does personalize the situation to a degree. Despite not being a major audiophile, I always turn the equalizer to flat before testing new speakers or headphones, and sometimes make small adjustments if I feel the speakers are lacking in a certain area. Judging by the comments, many others do similar.
Re-reading what I said, it seems like I'm calling the review completely irrelevant and useless, which isn't the case. I'm just saying that many of these people are somewhat justified in their criticism.