TechSpot

Laptop Vs. PDA --- How To Choose?

By daniel161
Nov 20, 2007
  1. Below is what I am looking for....

    Something with FAST bootup time
    WIFI
    Web access
    FTP Capable
    Text Editor Capable of saving files in mulitple extentions (.php, .txt, .htm)


    So I was looking at the Windows PDAs, do they have...


    WIFI
    Web browser
    text editor that can save in multiple formats
    FTP software?


    But then I was lookping at laptops....

    Is their a laptop that has a FAST boot-up, (under 30 seconds from cold boot)
    Runs XP or another stable OS
    WIFI
    has a kinda small size (body and screen)
    Is very durable, can tolerate being tossed arround with out body breakage or hard drive crash.


    Are their products that can do that?



    Thanks!



    --Daniel L
     
  2. GameJunkie72792

    GameJunkie72792 TS Maniac Posts: 274

  3. Nodsu

    Nodsu TS Rookie Posts: 5,837   +6

    The distinction between ultramobiles and PDAs is rather blurry..

    Keep in mind with a PDA:
    - you want a huge one (in a PDA sense) with a proper keyboard and screen if you intend to do any text editing that involves more than 20 characters.
    - it is hard to find free software for these things and the selection is limited anyway
    - in-device storage is rather limited and you would probaby have to invest in an additional storage device (the PDA would have to support memory cards or USB storage)
    - wifi may need an additional card - make sure you don't conflict with the previous point

    For laptops:
    - since you are comparing with PDAs, you probably want an ultramobile
    - it's getting harder and harder to find anything with XP
    - 30 seconds bootup is pretty much impossible unless you intend to keep the system virgin (no antivirus, firewall or any other resident software). One can always use sleep modes instead of poweroff of course.
    - make sure you can fit at least 512 megs of RAM in there
     
  4. GameJunkie72792

    GameJunkie72792 TS Maniac Posts: 274

    I figured the OQO is the best of both worlds ;)
     
  5. halo71

    halo71 TS Rookie Posts: 1,090

    IF what you list in your post are "THE" most important things to you. Then I'd go with a PDA. I can tell you from experience that I would stay away from the HP PDA's. Have had numerous problems with them from several different models. Other's in my office had very similiar if not the same issues. We ended up switching to Dell PDA's. And I can honestly say that the Dell PDA's have really stood up with no issues!

    This is what I have now.
    http://shopping.yahoo.com/p:Dell Axim X51v PDA:1993295121:page=user-reviews
     
  6. daniel161

    daniel161 TS Rookie Topic Starter Posts: 80

    Thank You

    OK, thanks everyone for your help! I now have a few things to work with...



    --Daniel L
     
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.

Similar Topics

Add New Comment

You need to be a member to leave a comment. Join thousands of tech enthusiasts and participate.
TechSpot Account You may also...