Maybe it's just me, but I've noticed that a lot of people who join the forums write in broken sentences or with poor grammar. I can understand if you really don't understand English well that a few mistakes is OK, but using capitals and periods to form proper sentences is to be expected from someone who has spoken English their whole lives (or most of)...

There was actually a poll about this, and I remember that most people said that quick spelling is only acceptable on MSN. I usually add a little note about spelling on my posts, but I feel that it isn't doing anything, so I'm going to make one post and leave it at that.

P.S. Excuse this poorly articulated rant, I'm becoming very annoyed when I can't understand the people I'm trying to help.

Amen to that! Hahaha.

Oh yeah, I forgot to mention! If I use poor grammar and punctuation, please excuse me! I'm not from here! :grinthumb

Just to start with my favourite reply to posts like these...

When making a post about grammar, spelling and general readability, it's often advisable to proof-read ones own post
(Though yours hardly had any faults in it)


But think about it. This is an international forum, with members from all over the world, and of all ages. Thus you can not expect everyone to be able to write a 100% grammatically correct post, since they may not be old enough to know the proper syntax/rules, might not have the needed education (due to school system in their mothercountry which has another language than english as their mother-tounge) or migth just not be very good to explain themselves in a written langauge.

I do however agree that if you want help you'll have to write a post which either is understandable, or willing to help us understand what you're trying to tell us by trying to re-word you post when asked (no matter how many times) until we get it.


Then you have the problem with general layout.
Some... like... to... use... a... lot... of... dots... in... their... posts... Some prefer to use 3 dots when either wanting the people reading the post to think about what is beeing/has been said... And some are very strict about only using one dot at the end of a line. And starting the next with a capital letter.

Here I would say that the two latter ways of using dots are the best, as the first might make the post undue hard to read, and thus reducing the chances of gettnig an answer.

When it comes to CAPITAL LETTERS, that's also bound up to what rules the mother-tongue, for that member, has.
So as long as they realize that THERE IS NO NEED TO USE CAPS LOCK AT ANY TIME WHEN WRITING A POST, just let it go.


My point is that you'll have to allow each member to have their own writing style since we're not all native english speaking here, and have no interest in limiting our member mass to just those who can write correct english.


And last, one little curio for you to ponder about.
When you compare the english of those who have it as their native language with those who have it as their second or third language, it is often the latter that has the best written english of the two groups.

A bit long post, but I too has certain viewpoints on the matter.


[EDIT]
Oh, and btw: I can also make a long post about the use of indentation, quoting & the likes, but I'm saving that for if this thread takes of or not
[/EDIT]

Some very good points there MrG. The point is everyone is not perfect and we all have to adapt to the various writing styles in the forum.

If you come across a post which you don't really understand, I m pretty sure that you can ask the person to elaborate more.

A spell checker for the reply box would be nice. Not sure if such a thing exists yet. I have noticed my own spelling getting worse since I started posting here :=).

We actually used to have that back when we used JawBreaker as our forum software.

It was very helpful for me as I have english as a second language, and I used it for allmost every post... These days I check the words I'm a bit unsure of with Dictionary.com...

But yeah, if it's a feature we could turn on I'd be very nice. Especially if it would also work in the quick reply box

The 6 O'clock new this ain't

Is it really necessary to PROOF READ a post? I could care less if someone spelled every word phonetically as long as their thoughts are logically constructed and articulated in a manner that is either easy to understand (in the case of questions/answers) or entertaining (in the case of discursions).

I'll admit that poor grammar grates on my nerves. Tense shifts, dangling participles, improper run-ons all tend to reflect poorly on the person doing the posting.
Case in point-

But who am I to criticize others?

And damit Akio, I may not always understand EXACTLY what you mean in your postings, but hey, I'm laughing along with your every "Hahaha!" :grinthumb <- Please note the correct capitalization of Hahaha.

There are 2 m's in grammar

Cut me some slack, I'm 12 years old...

And I wasn't saying the occasional spelling mistake isn't to be expected, I'm saying that certain people (who I won't name) have yet to make 1 post with any attempt at correct punctuation. I thought you guys would be a bit more mature than to insult a simple spelling mistake (yes, that means you, SNGX). I was just trying to establish some kind of standard for using proper english on the forums.

Julio: Isn't the kind of thing the mods could assist with? Not actually correcting people's spelling, but PMing them when they get to a certain number of posts with excessively poor grammar. I also think that we could find a small CGI program (or something of the likes) which can correct the spelling of words. I'll start looking tonight.

Glass houses...

Me(who else?), are you sure you're 12? You type so well! You must be in advanced classes. I mean, you get stuff that I don't! And I'm 23 come on! Maybe I'm just an *****....

I have also noticed that many people who post here are absolutely clueless about computers and make serious factual errors. I mean why do they post in tech forums when they have absolutely no computer skills? Perhaps the mods should delete the posts that offend common tech sense. Or maybe let us modify the really stupid posts..

Just in case I change my signature:

Aoccdrnig to a rscheearch at an Elingsh uinervtisy, it deosn't mttaer in waht oredr the ltteers in a wrod are, the olny iprmoetnt tihng is taht frist and lsat ltteer is at the rghit pclae. The rset can be a toatl mses and you can sitll raed it wouthit porbelm. Tihs is bcuseae we do not raed ervey lteter by itslef but the wrod as a wlohe.

I've seen that before, realBlackStuff. Wasn't it a study that determined that it doesn't matter what order letters are in , as long as the first and last letters are intact. It takes people longer to figure out what the words mean, though. (If I remember correctly)

Akio: Yes, I'm sure I'm 12. There was one time I forgot how old my little brother was, but I usually remeber (I think I can remember my own age). It just proves that if I can type properly, (almost) anybody can.

Maybe its better just to leave those posts untouched. Then they can live with the embarassment. Besides, I've seen posts that were wrong, yet the majority seemed to believe they were correct. in such a circumstance who is to dictate what is correct? Not all mods can be relied upon 100% of the time, as they are as fallable as anyone else.

I don't see anything wrong with mods posting to a thread when a poster seems misinformed, but I don't think they should be allowed to edit them for that reason. (See here: http://www.techspot.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=13282
As for serious errors, well...