So, eh.... Athlon question....

By jimbob11
Dec 13, 2005
  1. I got an Athlon 3400+ installed yesterday. It seems to be very fast (compared to my old pentium 1.5 at least) but I'm somewhat confused. The guy who fitted it said it was of a speed equivalent to a pentium 3.4ghz, but it's listed on my computer as 2.2ghz, and many games list the same requirement for both - 1.2 pentium or 1.2 Athlon, etc.
    So what is the Pentium equivalent, roughly? Will a 3400+ last me for a while?
  2. Nodsu

    Nodsu TS Rookie Posts: 5,837   +6

    Why do you think the word "equivalent" is used? Your CPU is roughly as powerful as a 3.4GHz P4, it does not run at 3.4GHz.

    1.2Ghz Athlons and Pentiums are something from two CPU generations ago, back then the clock speed actually had some meaning to it. Nowadays the GHz is not the number to look at.
  3. jimbob11

    jimbob11 TS Rookie Topic Starter

    I'm sorry, I was a bit vague. My worry was caused mainly by the following:
    Bloodlines minimum requirement for CPU: 1.2ghz Athlon or 1.2ghz Pentium.
    I also tried to install Half-Life 2: Lost Coast, and it told me "my 2.2ghz processor didn't meet requirements".
    Is this just a mark of the creator's ignorance as regards to how Athlons work? :confused:
  4. osram

    osram TS Rookie Posts: 47

    well the main reason for this is that intel and AMD have different cpu structures. im not a pro but in stupid language i think its because amd uses like 16 calculation pipelines (for example) and intel only 12. but physically you cannot only raise the amount of pipes to raise the frequency forever. because at some point too many parallel calculation pipes slow down the overall calculation.

    thats the reason why AMD uses for instance 2700+.. because its like an own "unit" of frequency.. due to their own amount of pipes.. specially designed for gaming etc.

    please note that lost coast for what i know needs HD-supporting graphicscard or whatever u need for that ****. so it needs a pretty high minimal system requirement/features.
  5. jettwo

    jettwo TS Rookie Posts: 17

    Modern CPU's are really measured by actions per clock-tick cycle. Megahertz speed really doesn't apply. By lowering the megahertz speed you reduce tempeture, then increasing bus speed, pipeline architecture, etc, you will increase processing speed or power. I would estimate the equivelant would be a Pentium 4 / 3.4 Ghz at least. Your AMD 3400 should be more than adequate for quite sometime.
  6. mailpup

    mailpup TS Special Forces Posts: 6,964   +355

    Either that or I've heard there is a problem in the way Steam's pre-testing thing measures AMD cpus. Yours should be good enough but Steam inaccurately doesn't think so. Maybe they'll fix it.
  7. jimbob11

    jimbob11 TS Rookie Topic Starter

    Ah. That would make sense.

    Thanks for clearing things up, all of you. I mainly created this topic because I got a bit worried after Steam pretty much declared my new, expensive, powerful CPU borderline obsolete. :D
  8. mossimoboy

    mossimoboy TS Rookie Posts: 121

    eh, Lost-Coast isnt really worth playing anyway, its like a 10 minute demo.
  9. jimbob11

    jimbob11 TS Rookie Topic Starter

    From what I've heard, it could be replaced with ten minutes of the graphic artists masturbating and nobody would notice.
  10. mailpup

    mailpup TS Special Forces Posts: 6,964   +355

    I played it today. It is short but it's more of a demo of how things could look. It might be a test to see how many people download it which gives them an idea of how many machines are capable of supporting the high end requirements and whether the public is ready for a full length game.
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.

Similar Topics

Add New Comment

You need to be a member to leave a comment. Join thousands of tech enthusiasts and participate.
TechSpot Account You may also...