Weekend Open Forum: Have you used Apple Pay, Google Wallet, or other mobile payment method?

By Jos
Oct 31, 2014
Post New Reply
  1. Contactless payments have been around for a while, but with the arrival of Apple Pay the technology has been grabbing headlines. Now a power struggle has started, with big-name retailers pushing their CurrentC alternative, which in its current state seems...

    Read more
  2. seefizzle

    seefizzle TS Addict Posts: 269   +138

    I have been using Google Wallet since it has become available. It works in A LOT more places than you probably think. So does Apple pay for that matter.

    I install the credit card pin pads you use at cash registers in retail stores. I'm talking about the pin pads that you the customer swipe your own card and punch in your pin yourself. This is called "integrated credit", meaning that the credit card transactions are integrated within the point of sale system. The pos terminal tells the pin pad what amount to charge and exchanges information to send out to the credit card processors. "Non integrated" credit card terminals are the kind where the cashier takes your card and swipes it through some reader. These machines don't talk to the point of sale system.

    You can say I know a lot about the subject matter.

    I'd like to point out a few things about this topic for people that are unfamiliar with this stuff. Functionally there is no difference between the way that Google Wallet works and Apple Pay works. At least in terms of the way the transaction is processed they work exactly the same way. Apple isn't doing anythe special here folks, sorry to burst the bubble. NFC is a communication method. The magnetic stripe on a credit card is a communication method as well. The numbers you send to the pin pad with a magnetic stripe on a plastic card are the exact same numbers you send to the pin pad when you're running a NFC payment. There's no difference in terms of the data that is seen by the pin pad. The pin pad is just the delivery man. It takes whatever communication you give it, and it passes it on to the POS system, then to the bank. To put it in another way, for all intents and purposes, the pin pad doesn't really know whether or not you're swiping a card or using the mag reader. It doesn't care.

    Functionally there is no difference between Apple Pay and Google Wallet. Anywhere one of them works the other one will work. There's no way to turn off Apple Pay and leave Google Wallet active. It just doesn't work that way. NFC is either on or off.

    With that said, a whole lot more pin pads work with Apple Pay and Google Wallet than you think. I have spoken with the manufacturers of the major credit card pin pad systems and I have confirmed exactly which pin pad models work with Apple Pay and Google Wallet. I've also tested every single one of these models in person. If you would like to know what pin pads you can use your phone to pay with, do a google search of these models and look at the pictures. If you're too lazy for that, just look for the dongle attachment on the top of most pin pads. If it has a dongle on top, more than likely it'll work with NFC payments.

    The pin pads below accept both Apple Pay and Google Wallet transactions. They're extremely common and you've probably seen these in stores plenty of times and not known that they work. This is not a definitive list these are just the ones I know for sure work.

    Equinox L5200
    Equinox L5300
    (Requires dongle)

    Verifone Mx870
    Verifone Mx915
    Verifone Mx925
    (Requires dongle)

    Ingenico iSC Touch 480

    My opinion about NFC payments is that I think they're great. We should have been doing this crap five years ago as far as I'm concerned. I've been trying to sell these kinds of pin pads for years but no one has cared about NFC payments. I find it to be both fascinating and frustrating that now that Apple has NFC people are just now becoming interested. Apple sure has a way of herding the masses of *****s to the newer technologies.

    Also, I don't care what is written about the security vulnerabilities of NFC communications... NFC payments are about a billion times safer in all practicality. They're safer because if a system is new enough to process NFC payments, that system is inherently safer than a system that's running older pieces of junk terminals. The software is probably more up to date, they're probably following more of the security protocols such as firewalls, network securities, strong passwords etc. The newer a system is the more safe it is. I personally trust an NFC payment a lot more than a regular credit card transaction. Ask the cashiers and store owners about NFC payments. The more the public demands NFC, the more store owners will put the pin pads in, the more secure the systems will be, and it keeps me working.
    MilwaukeeMike likes this.
  3. TomSEA

    TomSEA TechSpot Chancellor Posts: 2,550   +594

  4. I haven't used these systems and I won't, because they introduce at least two more points of failure into the transaction processing: 1) Google Wallet and 2) NFC.

    With technology, the fewer steps between you and what you want, the better. Adding more steps just means more ways to fail and more places for everybody to point fingers.
  5. Skidmarksdeluxe

    Skidmarksdeluxe TS Evangelist Posts: 6,339   +1,938

    I don't see any reason to use any of these new methods.
  6. cliffordcooley

    cliffordcooley TS Guardian Fighter Posts: 8,430   +2,822

    Paypal only!
  7. Skidmarksdeluxe

    Skidmarksdeluxe TS Evangelist Posts: 6,339   +1,938

    Anyway these payment methods aren't available in South Africa yet, we tend to lag a few light years behind when it comes to these type of things, it's cash, credit card, debit card or take a hike are the the only options available.
  8. TitoBXNY

    TitoBXNY TS Addict Posts: 225   +46

    No reason to yet.
  9. seefizzle

    seefizzle TS Addict Posts: 269   +138

    Google wallet transactions are tokenized, meaning they make up a fake credit card number to send to the pin pad. So even if it was stolen, it would be useless. It only works once. Also, I doubt Google's getting hacked any time soon. NFC transactions are inherently safer than plastic cards.
  10. JakeT

    JakeT TS Member Posts: 74   +20

    Thanks for the info seefizzle.

    Here in Canada, I don't see any of the dongles you mention but I'll look at the pin pads more closely from now on.
  11. tonylukac

    tonylukac TS Evangelist Posts: 1,292   +55

    I use google wallet but not remotely. It's what pays me when they buy my android apps from the google play store on their phones.
  12. EClyde

    EClyde TS Maniac Posts: 617   +143

    No I keep my money closer then that
  13. EClyde

    EClyde TS Maniac Posts: 617   +143

    What's your app?

Similar Topics

Add New Comment

You need to be a member to leave a comment. Join thousands of tech enthusiasts and participate.
TechSpot Account You may also...