Apple cripples maps and search results for Chinese iPhone 4

By on September 29, 2010, 9:41 AM
When we reported that the iPhone 4 was headed to China, there was no mention about how Apple would cripple the device under the government's orders. Those details are starting to surface, thanks to Ogle Earth. The maps app on the Chinese iPhone 4 can reportedly only display Google's Chinese government-approved version of the world, and it also censors Google's search results. The problem is worse this time around because the censorship is hardwired.

In China, the iPhone's maps app, which is powered by Google Maps, must show the borders the way China insists they should look like. For example, the Arunachal Pradesh region shows up as part of China, even though it's part of India. Up until now, Chinese iPhone owners who took their device outside of the country's borders, or who used a VPN to fool the app into thinking they were elsewhere, would see the more accurate version of Maps.

With the iPhone 4, however, Apple has apparently agreed to hardwire the Chinese version of maps, meaning users will see their phones display the borders as the Chinese government demands, regardless of where they are. Furthermore, the censored maps data is missing a lot of street data for the rest of the world.

On top of all this, Ogle Earth also reports that users of China's iPhone 4 are finding that searches conducted via Safari's Google search bar are getting redirected to They have to manually click a link to get redirected to, the search giant's unfiltered Hong Kong site, much like how the redirect process works on computers in China.

Once again, the situation becomes worse when we realize the Chinese iPhone 4 forces users to redirect from no matter what their phone's region is set to (and a VPN makes no difference). Everywhere else in the world, the iPhone 4's Safari search bar is dependent on their regional settings, meaning Apple has been significantly tweaking the Chinese iPhone 4 to appease the government. Previous Chinese iPhone versions allowed users to sign on to a VPN to bypass entirely.

These decisions make both Apple and the Chinese government look worse than the two already did with previous crippled versions of the iPhone. Apple's first iPhone in China was an iPhone 3G without WiFi support.

User Comments: 5

Got something to say? Post a comment
Guest said:

"the Arunachal Pradesh region shows up as part of China, even though it's part of India"

--it's disputed territory, take a look at where it is in Google Maps relative to India and China, respectively, and you'll see why China claims it.

treeski treeski said:

I guess Apple wasn't on the Google bandwagon with objecting to restrictions...

Wendig0 Wendig0, TechSpot Paladin, said:

The maps app on the Chinese iPhone 4 can reportedly only display Google's Chinese government-approved version of the world

Does this mean Apple will flatten out the images of Earth for the Chinese government?

Great.... I've been thinking about this for too long and now my nose is bleeding!

KG363 KG363 said:

I hate the Chinese government and their controlling ways. I can't see how the Chinese people allow it. Maybe it'll take the next generation to become unsatisfied.

tengeta tengeta said:

These companies always talk about bettering the world but they only do it when its environmental. Own up to your words for once and just pull your product out of the country, if The Chinese people have to deal with falling behind in technology they will get mad enough to revolt, but instead they get half functional devices that seem to string them along.

Load all comments...

Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.