More on WinXP SP2

You want better security? Then you're just going to have to put up with any issues that occur. So far I've only experienced one issue (the latest nVidia IDE drivers caused my PC to spontaneously reboot, so I had to revert back to the Microsoft drivers), otherwise I think SP2 is well worth installing, because security is very important. You can't have it both ways.

One problem ive run into with SP2 is when I'm using BitTornado my computer only lasts from 10 minutes to an hour before it spontaneously reboots. Its kind of annoying when I have to restart downloads right after they get up to speed.

SP2 messes with a lot of software... I thought they tested this? As for Security... I don't think it's THAT important. Some people are paranoid about security loop holes and they seem to take it more seriously than anyone else. I've had trojans and blah blah, but as long as you're aware, , you can handle it... right?

Originally posted by Strakian
I've had trojans and blah blah, but as long as you're aware, , you can handle it... right?

Click to expand...

But are 90% of the computer users out there aware of the problem? No, most of them are not.

Because if they were, we wouldn't have the problem of virus and trojans that we have today.

This is an enthusiast site, and as such it's easy to forget that not everyone else has as much knowledge about computers as we do.

So I think SP2 is a step in the right direction, considering most computer users are not enthusiast, and we don't want to revert back to the days when most were (as then hardware and software didn't evolve as fast)...

I wasn't refering to other people, I was refering to myself. Obviously most users don't have a clue about this stuff, and sure it's good for them, but I don't think it's worht it for me, not yet anyway.

Originally posted by Supra
One problem ive run into with SP2 is when I'm using BitTornado my computer only lasts from 10 minutes to an hour before it spontaneously reboots. Its kind of annoying when I have to restart downloads right after they get up to speed.

Click to expand...

that's not SP2.

I bet you have ZoneAlarm installed......do you?

I bet you have ZoneAlarm installed......do you?

Click to expand...

Actually no, I only have a hardware firewall. I researched the problem a little more and found out that SP2 limits the number of concurrent TCP/IP connections to 10 and bittornado requires much more than that. I increased the number to 50 and now it lasts for several hours before it reboots. I may try to increase it to 100 and see if it does better.

Hmm.. limiting connections is one thing.. fixing security holes is another

Am I the only one who finds it somewhat amusing that among the vast amounts of programs that dont get along with SP2 a good amount of Microsoft products are on the list? Way to go guys!

So its going to break:
Starcraft
Nero
Outlook
Max Payne 2
and basically any Norton product you have on your system...

That doesn't provide me with much encouragement to upgrade.

Same here SNGX... i think ill wait a while for a more friendly release to come out.

If you read the list, then you'd see that sp2 doesn't break all the programs on the list. For many of the programs listed, sp2 simply requires that users check their firewall settings etc. I am running Norton AV, and Outlook 2003, which are on the list, yet they are working fine for me. SP2 check that your AV software virus definitions are up to date and warns you whenever new definition files are available. This only works if you AV software is compatable with SP2. Hardly an issue as you can switch off notifications. I've yet to find anything significant that won't work with SP2, though I am sure it will happen.

Yeh I can read.

I know things still can work, but there has to be some issue or they wouldn't have made the list. In most cases I'm sure a patch or upgrade will be sufficient. But when you are on dial up on your home machine its a bit of an inconvienience to download and install patches for every piece of software that no longer functions properly under SP2.

Does it say "Microsoft Windows XP" on the list? Heheh only kidding.

I seem to remember a similar list of broken apps shortly after XP was initially released, and you people sound surprised. Also, SP2 has just been released, actually it isn't even available on windows update for most users yet, you have to expect it to break everything, its the MS way. When XP was released it broke half your apps, later some updates fixed most of it. SP1 did the same, and now SP2 is going to do the same, why do you think "Big Blue" hasn't updated any of its internal machines to SP2 yet? I can also tell you that Dell hasn't updated to SP2 yet and won't be anytime soon on its internal systems, or its support systems.

SW Engineer

Man, just drop $50 the next time browsing (or out shopping) and buy a firewall. It'll run circles around XP's "free" firewall anyway. If you have a home network (lots of folks do nowadays), everyone will be protected regardless of whether they have upgraded or not. As far as the spam guard and spyware protection goes, I need to be convinced Bill did a good job before I trust them.

As it stands I use my router/firewall, a $30 popup blocker (it's $30, so get over it), Norton AV and run the free Lavasoft Ad-Aware periodically. For this I get the peace of mind of not wondering with Bill broke this week and can hang loose until the the discussion groups verify that MickeySoft's inevitable fixes for SP2 actually work.

Windows... It's only a matter of time until the nix shells make it attactive enough for folks to just tell Bill to take a powder...

Security of SP2 has been down played alot lately. Any major bugs found in the last couple of days?

- Jaynon

SNGX1275 said:

So its going to break:
Starcraft
Nero
Outlook
Max Payne 2
and basically any Norton product you have on your system.

Click to expand...

I actually had NAV 2003 on my system, but something in the Service Pack prevented it from scanning my computer. I uninstalled the service pack and now it runs just fine. I'm just going to go get Norton Internet Security and pray that SP2 doesn't download. It really wasn't that great anyway.

I'm just going to go get Norton Internet Security and pray that SP2 doesn't download.

Click to expand...

Well, we all have personal preference, though personally, I'd be looking at that statement in reverse.

Spike said:

Well, we all have personal preference, though personally, I'd be looking at that statement in reverse.

Click to expand...

All I want is a firewall, AV, spyware blocker, spam blocker, and that's it. Nothing else. I don't trust Microsoft that much anyway, because it continually changes my settings during updates, when I don't want it to. Fortuantely, Spybot S&D can detect and stop this kidn of activity.

Unregistered said:

All I want is a firewall, AV, spyware blocker, spam blocker, and that's it. Nothing else. I don't trust Microsoft that much anyway, because it continually changes my settings during updates, when I don't want it to. Fortuantely, Spybot S&D can detect and stop this kidn of activity.

Click to expand...

Sorry, forgot to login before posting.

Nothing wrong with wanting these things. I just wouldn't go out and pay for norton to get them. there are better, and free alternatives out there.

as for updates changing your system, I'll admit there are a few changes made sometimes on account of MS wanting to make sure even uncaring/unknowing users don't leave obvious things open, but the updates also fix holes in the software itself, some of which are still exploitable even if you are generically protected.

It's a personal choice at the end of the day, but it should be an informed one.