Spread the love! TechSpot Tech Gift Shortlist 2017

Computer Woes (Long Story)


Is the MB Bad? (Needs Replaced AGAIN)

  1. Yes

    0 vote(s)
  2. No

    0 vote(s)
By FoxFang ยท 7 replies
Apr 23, 2007
  1. Okay guys, for my epic tale of woe, I present the following.

    I've built eight or so computers for my family over the years. I'm typing on one right now. But for some reason the gaming rig I put together for my sister about two years ago never has seemed to work right. She beleives It's demonic posession. I'm writing to solicit any fresh insight on the situation.

    I'll begin at the beginning, hopefully getting the full scope of the situation will help any would-be advisors.

    Started out simple enough, just a nice middle-range game rig. Original MB was an MSI K8N-Neo2 socket 939 with an AMD athalon 3500. Graphics were handled by a Nvidia G-Force 6800gt (remember this was about two years ago, not a bad card for the time.) in 8X agp. Storage is A WD 74 gig 10,000 rpm spindle SATA HD.

    Partially, I do admit it's my fault. Got a bad motherboard, but since there wasn't the scratch for a new one right off the bat, I wracked my brains trying to trouble shoot away every other conceivable problem. Replaced the video card, had the memory tested, (passed just fine) flashed the Bios to latest version, disabled the onboard sound and installed soundblaster PCI card. Nope. System was still volatile and extremely unstable. Particularly when handling anything multimedia related. I was busy with work, and my sister gave up on her computer for almost a year, until she wanted to try World of Warcraft, and she drug the beast back out into the sunlight.

    After finally bellying up to the bar, I replaced the motherboard. Swapping the MSI out for a FoxConn NF4SK8AA-8KRS. This necessitated an upgrade to a PCI-E Video Card, for which I selected a Diamond Radeon X1550 256 meg card. Other components remained the same. After crossing fingers and saying a prayer, computer POSTed without issue. Windows XP professional went on smooth as silk, and I sighed a breath of releif. UNTIL I tried to load WoW for her. Install went just fine, opening intro movies played just fine, but when it goes to the intial screen to accept the EULA. The computer will either lock up hard, or reboot. Yeah.. Great. A couple of times, windows wanted to send in an error report, and asking for details revealed the problem as a stop error. Driver confict, whoopie. Well, after updating the sound, video, and N-force 4 drivers, I'm beginning to wonder if the bad luck has followed me to the new board. When I tried to install the old Sound Blaster 24 bit card from the old machine, something funny happened. When I installed it into the first PCI slot, the computer suddenly wouldn't POST. When removed, it started up again no problem. When I tried the second or third PCI slot. The computer simply dosen't recognize it's there.

    This board was ordered from NewEgg.com, so I've no worries about being able to return it. Just, before I do, I was looking for a second opinion or a concensus from other tech-heads. Is this a bad board, or am I missing something?

    Any constructive comments or suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
  2. CCT

    CCT TS Evangelist Posts: 2,653   +6

    PSU data?

    Have you checked the hard drive with WD's diagnostics?

    Memory test? Memtest86 for 50 runs?
  3. FoxFang

    FoxFang TS Rookie Topic Starter

    PSU is an ultra 500watt Xconnect (I beleive, not staring right at it. ) Hmm.. It did only have the 20 pin ATX connectors instead of the 24 pin the MB asked for. The manual said the MB would function with the 20 pin however, and it was installed correctly. (POSTed properly with first startup.)

    Yes, memory has been checked out. (Not even by me, I took it in to a tech bench to have it independantly tested. Came back fine)

    I have not run checks on the WD HD yet. Will get those done now. I am curious though how that would seemingly affect only wow and games, and not windows or any other applications.
  4. AtK SpAdE

    AtK SpAdE TechSpot Chancellor Posts: 1,495

    The whole sound card thing makes me believe you have a bunk mobo.
  5. MetalX

    MetalX TechSpot Chancellor Posts: 1,388

    I think you need to get a 24-pin connection. If it accepts 24 pins, that's how many you should use, even if it says that it works with 20.
  6. CCT

    CCT TS Evangelist Posts: 2,653   +6

  7. raspygold

    raspygold TS Rookie

    I know that when I bought my new PSU, it has a 20pin and an extra 4pin power connecter, and they actually both went into the 24pin connection. Does yours happen to have a similar thing?
  8. Tedster

    Tedster Techspot old timer..... Posts: 6,000   +15

    random errors are generally attributed to bad RAM or bad PSU. If you are having hardware issues, replace the PSU and test the RAM with memtest 86+ for 7 or more passes.
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.

Similar Topics

Add New Comment

You need to be a member to leave a comment. Join thousands of tech enthusiasts and participate.
TechSpot Account You may also...