onesmartidiot
Posts: 95 +0
I've been a loyal WD customer since 2002, but lately I have lost confidence in their drives.
First drive to fail:
WD800. Bought in 2003 brand new, used in a athlon xp machine every day for a year. when i built my amd64 machine it was only used from time to time. The tower was never pushed over, kicked, etc.
When the drive turns on it spins up then ticks off immediately. it will do this about 5-6 times before it just stays off.
This drive had important pictures on it that i may not have back-ups of.
Second drive to fail:
almost a month later, the WD 80gig from my dads dell 8200 crashed and would not allow windows to be re-installed.
it was quickly replaced by a WD 320gig drive.
i brought the dell 80 gig back to life somehow as a storage drive.
Third drive to fail
WD 200gig
bought new in 2004 for my athlon 64 system. was never abused or swapped out. Last week it pooped out and no computer/ external enclosure i put it in will recognize it. I tried taking the dell 80 gig and installing windows on it for my new pc, now it is doing the same thing.
After this I will no longer buy WD drives, seems like they have a 3-5 year lifespan which is ridiculous.
I have a hitachi 250gig drive in an external enclosure that i bought in 2003 also which has been dropped, knocked over, kicked, punted (accidentally of course) and it still works fine.
I have a maxtor 2 gig drive which is useless for xp but it still works perfect.
What are some of your experiences with the different brands? I'm looking to purchase a new drive that isn't WD. If its more than 40 bucks it will be sata 3gb/s. im looking into hitachi because it seems to be a reliable brand. Samsung is also cheap but my family has had issues in the past with samsung electronics.
also the budget is 60-70 bucks.
also, is there anyway to revive the broken drives? obviously the first one is gone, im saving it for one day when i take it for data recovery. but the other 2 that spin up and click fine but arent reconized, is there anything i can do?
i have a brand new core 2 duo system that i cant use because none of my drives work! im a sad little boy right now lol
thanks
First drive to fail:
WD800. Bought in 2003 brand new, used in a athlon xp machine every day for a year. when i built my amd64 machine it was only used from time to time. The tower was never pushed over, kicked, etc.
When the drive turns on it spins up then ticks off immediately. it will do this about 5-6 times before it just stays off.
This drive had important pictures on it that i may not have back-ups of.
Second drive to fail:
almost a month later, the WD 80gig from my dads dell 8200 crashed and would not allow windows to be re-installed.
it was quickly replaced by a WD 320gig drive.
i brought the dell 80 gig back to life somehow as a storage drive.
Third drive to fail
WD 200gig
bought new in 2004 for my athlon 64 system. was never abused or swapped out. Last week it pooped out and no computer/ external enclosure i put it in will recognize it. I tried taking the dell 80 gig and installing windows on it for my new pc, now it is doing the same thing.
After this I will no longer buy WD drives, seems like they have a 3-5 year lifespan which is ridiculous.
I have a hitachi 250gig drive in an external enclosure that i bought in 2003 also which has been dropped, knocked over, kicked, punted (accidentally of course) and it still works fine.
I have a maxtor 2 gig drive which is useless for xp but it still works perfect.
What are some of your experiences with the different brands? I'm looking to purchase a new drive that isn't WD. If its more than 40 bucks it will be sata 3gb/s. im looking into hitachi because it seems to be a reliable brand. Samsung is also cheap but my family has had issues in the past with samsung electronics.
also the budget is 60-70 bucks.
also, is there anyway to revive the broken drives? obviously the first one is gone, im saving it for one day when i take it for data recovery. but the other 2 that spin up and click fine but arent reconized, is there anything i can do?
i have a brand new core 2 duo system that i cant use because none of my drives work! im a sad little boy right now lol
thanks