Originally posted by filthy_mcnasty
i dont agree. my argument is that your public ip address is the only thing they actually see.
Correct.
as a computer programmer that has dealt with this sort of coding i promise you that other computers on the internet must see you as your actual ip.
Don't throw credentials in peoples faces, it is quite rude - And believe me, StormBringer is an extremely intelligent person who is very well reasoned. You don't have to stoop to that to argue with him.
if they get the address of your router and try sending something to it, it winds up back on their own network. to other people on the internet your router assumes your IP address.
now if you sit behind a router and try to find your actual ip address you'll probably just get your local one *similiar to the router one* but other people out there never see you as 192.168.whatever.
For being a "computer programmer that has dealt with this sort of coding" you seem to be pretty clueless as to how a router functions. All routers have at minimum two IP addresses, one for each network it is connected to. Most home users' routers will have one external address on one network, then one internal address on another network. The internal network should be one of the three reserved blocks, 10.*, 192.168.*, or 172.smth.*
however i would imagine this is only the case if and only if the router has it's own unique IP address on the internet at large, which would be weird.
That is not weird at all. Most DSL and Cable users will have a DSL or cable Router that has the external address assigned to it by the ISP open to the public. Some exceptions include circumstances in which the router has a reserved (LAN) IP on both sides, such as a 192.168.1.1 address for internal and 192.168.0.1 for external. In these cases, the ISP is intentionally putting that user (or users) behind a seperate network, which is perfectly fine as long as the user does not require direct incoming communications.
i dont mean to argue with you storm, i just have never seen a case where a website or any other computer saw my router ip.
Well, then you would be wrong. Sure, nothing from the outside can see the routers
internal IP, but eventually, no matter what, the routers external IP will be used and visible.
An example for my home:
(the internet)
|
|
|
(My router [66.15.117.2])
<-->
(Other end of my router[192.168.0.100])
|
|
|
(36-port switch)
192.168.0.1 through 192.168.0.30 - My home network