Editors Liked

  • Epic 48player sea battles are among the most thrilling moments to be found in the genre, Naval combat mechanics are tactical and compelling, Quests are well written and contribute to the overarching political climate, The relationship between the playerdr
  • Great sea battles; "conquer the Caribbean" meta-game; player-based economy; fun and well-written quests
  • Great Economic Structure, Unique Shipbased Combat, Engaging Gameplay

Editors Didn't Like

  • Steep learning curve, particularly where the economy is concerned, Ground combat isnt very good, Some interface quirks and other minor issues
  • Brutal learning curve; bugs; avatar combat; poor UI
  • Potential of SOE Screwing Up Like Star Wars Galaxies, Niche Market