Editors Liked

  • Some clever puzzles
  • Innovative "memory" system
  • Good music
  • Tight storyline that ties up everything by the end
  • Excellent voice acting
  • Novel interface that actually improves on a very old standard

Editors Didn't Like

  • Poorly conceived and written
  • Puzzles are often contrived or confusing
  • Old school graphics may not be for everyone
  • Could use a little more humor to leaven all the heavy drama
  • Pixel hunting puzzles