Editors Liked

  • Lots of class, weapons, and tech options. First game to let Xbox 360 and Vista owners to play together
  • Balanced gameplay; dwarves are cool

Editors Didn't Like

  • No singleplayer; limited gametypes and maps. Requires Vista, but no DX10 support
  • Sloppy, amateurish feel; surprisingly sparse amount of content for price & pedigree; unstable servers