Editors Liked

  • Very well written, felt less rushed, The humor is very wellexecuted, Controls are a vast improvement
  • Very fun and hilarious game play. You get to create a unique pirate face and explore the inside of a manatee (and the return of Murray)
  • Great puzzles, Great jokes, The inimitable Morgan LeFlay, The incomparable Murray

Editors Didn't Like

  • Story can be cheesy at times, Puzzle difficulty inconsitent, Why does Guybrush have to turn puke green??
  • No more Island exploring, possibly too much manatee exploring
  • Those stupid reworked walking controls