Reviewers Liked

  • New big ship to sail, firstperson adventures to experience
  • Open world is your oyster, Customization is extensive, Combat is challenging, Some graphical bright spots
  • Fast action, pretty graphics, pirates!, sail ships!

Reviewers Didn't Like

  • Doesn’t add _that_ much to the base game experience
  • Clipping issues, More than a few bugs, Trading mechanics aren't very deep, Interface is clunky and confusing
  • Bad leadin/tutorial and UI, occasionally mystifying gameplay design