Editors Liked

  • Mayhem and wonder can lurk behind every bend, every hill, and every mountain
  • Main quest line is an improvement from Oblivion
  • Dual-wielding and Shouts make combat more fun
  • Enchanting, making potions, and crafting weapons is easy
  • Enough improvements to the Bethesda RPG formula
  • Great new leveling and combat system

Editors Didn't Like

  • Technical issues could ruin moments for some players
  • It's too easy to go into "sneak" mode when backing up with the control stick
  • You will forget what it means to sleep or have meaningful social interactions outside of the game
  • Combat isn't very visceral, and victories and losses feel unearned
  • Menus and interface are terrible
  • No multiplayer mode