To many fans of the original city building simulation series, the idea of an online multiplayer game that required even solo players to be connected to the internet at all times seemed like a recipe for disaster. Maxis' latest creation is easily the most compelling SimCity I've played since the 1989 original.

It's also a disaster.

The weekend before the game's March 5 launch, I had a chance to experience SimCity the way everyone is supposed to be experiencing it right now. The handful of press participating barely put a dent on the special servers EA set up for the event. The game played (for the most part) flawlessly, giving early reviewers an exquisite taste of the collaborative multiplayer that defines the release. I saw what the developers no doubt wanted every player to see post-launch a new SimCity capable of bringing together people from across the planet to strive towards a common goal. It was glorious.

I collected that early experience in an article titled "SimCity Won (and Broke) My Heart in Just Three Days." I had no idea how apropos that headline would become.

That first, teasing taste was followed by a nightmare for everyone involved. There were problems downloading the game. Problems connecting to servers. Problems getting together with friends to play during the brief moments when everything seemed to be working perfectly. While EA and Maxis work aggressively on a solution to these issues, player frustration and outrage continues to build.

SimCity Review
WHY: One of the most compelling entries in the esteemed city building simulation series, SimCity's substantial connectivity problems aren't exactly giving players a choice in the matter.

Developer: Maxis
Platforms: PC
Release Date: March 5
Type of game: City Building Simulation.

What I played: Built, maintained and destroyed multiple cities during the press early start event. Once the game launched I attempted to collaborate with other members of the Kotaku staff on our own private region, but only two of us (myself included) managed to successfully play long enough to build anything of lasting value.

My Two Favorite Things

  • Laying down regions and watching them grow organically and change dynamically based on the objects I place around them.
  • Working together with other players for the good of an entire region adds meaning and purpose to my virtual cities. This is what a social game should be.

My Two Least-Favorite Things

  • There's never enough space for my ambition in these tiny plots of land, and claiming multiples in one region doesn't scratch my megalopolis itch.
  • I don't mind a game that requires an always-on internet connection, as long as it returns the favor.

Made-to-Order Back-of-Box Quotes

  • "Hey guys. HEY GUYS. GUYS. Look at my city. No no, look at it now."
    -Mike Fahey, Kotaku.com
  • "Unable to connect to the Made-to-Order Back-of-Box Quotes server. Please try again."
    -Mike Fahey.
  • "It says I'm online? But I'm at Wal-Mart, and the PC the game is loaded on is unplugged."
    -Mike Fahey.

I am not filled with outrage; only disappointment, fueled by the knowledge that somewhere beyond these technical issues there's an outstanding game waiting to be played.

The original SimCity is one of the greatest computer games of all time. When now-legendary game designer Will Wright realized that using the map editor he'd created for the game Raid on Bungling Bay was more entertaining than the game itself, he gave that editor to the world, creating an entirely new genre in the process. The creative freedom SimCity allowed was intoxicating. I couldn't tell you how long I played when I first launched the game the days ran together. I would fall asleep in my computer chair, wake up and continue playing.

Over the years, freedom and I have had a falling out. Giving me a sandbox to play in with little supervision is a surefire way to ensure I wander away from the sandbox, possibly into busy traffic. So much of my time is not my own these days that I need a more directed experience. I require more than my own devices.

This brave new multiplayer SimCity grants me the focus I need to once again lose myself in the minutiae of running a virtual town. The success of my creation is intricately tied to the prosperity of other players'. They depend on me to foster a community of wealthy citizens that will flock to their shops to spend their simoleons. I depend on them to provide sewage treatment and medical services so that the wealthy citizens drawn to my tourist mecca don't die of cholera.

The SimCity series has always been a balancing act, with players struggling to maintain the right ratio of residential to industrial to commercial, all the while ensuring that enough funds are invested in services to make sure the whole thing doesn't go up in flames. It's just now there are multiple performers in every region, taking turns walking the tightrope while the others hold the safety net (or drop it, as the case may be).

The multiplayer aspect also allows for excellent opportunities to show off your city-planning skills. The creative gamer thrives in the new SimCity, thanks in no small part to the addition of curved and free-form road placement and the ability of residential, commercial and industrial zones to conform to these wild lines. These color-coded areas are painted more than placed, fresh buildings sprouting like architectural flowers that blow in the breeze of every little change the player makes. The GlassBox engine is a remarkable machine, transforming a technical process into something organic and beautiful. It's a joy to watch its work unfold, both from the sky above and at street level.

Players more interested in straight lines and statistics will find plenty to love in SimCity as well. The game is filled with color-coded maps that communicate a wealth of complex information in the most efficient way possible. The interface, aside from the odd obtuse bits, is amazingly intuitive without feeling dumbed-down. Micro-management is an option, but not a necessity. It's one of the game's greatest strengths catering to multiplayer play styles while remaining completely accessible (I'm talking mechanics, not connection) to all.

Of course there are downsides. I wish the individual city plots were larger or expandable, giving my city room to stretch out, perhaps link up with other players' creations. I wish I understood how trade depots work, one of a few obtuse mechanics in an otherwise intuitive game.

And I wish I could play consistently. That would be nice.

Team Kotaku had big plans for the SimCity launch. We set up a private region so we could further explore the symbiotic relationship between cities. I staked out my claim, a circular piece of land I decided to dedicate to tourism and travel. Stephen Totilo grabbed a plot, his city feeding mine with waste and sewage disposal. Between the two of us we managed to unlock two Great Works the Arcology and the International Airport massive undertakings built in special spots on the regional map, requiring cities to work together to harvest the resources necessary for their completion.

None of the others made it into the game.

Chris Person was able to claim two plots, but both bugged out before he could lay a single road. He can't access them, and we can't delete them. Jason Schreier hasn't been able to connect. Neither has Kirk Hamilton, who received my invitation to join the region yesterday two days after I sent it. Our grand plan will never be realized.

I understand the frustration and anger that players are feeling. Over the past three days I've slept maybe seven hours total, waking from shorts naps taken while waiting for server queues, maintenance downtime, server disconnects and the like. Each of those seven hours was spent in my computer chair, fearing I might miss an opportunity if I wandered off to the bedroom. I feel like I did when I played the original SimCity, only now I'm much older and a lot less happy.

SimCity's launch is more than just a disaster it's a tragedy, because somewhere beyond the rage, pain and technical issues there's an amazing game that I'm dying to play.

We'll revisit that Not Yet once EA gets the servers to a point where not playing is no longer mandatory.