Debris from the International Space Station confirmed to have hit a Florida home

Daniel Sims

Posts: 1,377   +43
Staff
What just happened? Space agencies constantly monitor and often direct debris entering the Earth's atmosphere, usually determining the risk of damage to be minimal. Most material burns up in the atmosphere, and what does reach the surface usually lands in the ocean. However, that wasn't the case for one Florida resident.

Update (April 17): NASA has confirmed that a piece of hardware survived re-entry through Earth's atmosphere and impacted a house in Naples, Florida last month. Analysis conducted at Kennedy Space Center in Florida verified the homeowner's suspicions that the object belonged to the International Space Station.

In March 2021, NASA employed the ISS's robotic arm to jettison a cargo pallet loaded with obsolete nickel hydride batteries. The discarded hardware, weighing approximately 5,800 pounds, was expected to completely disintegrate during its atmospheric re-entry on March 8, 2024. Nevertheless, a small piece survived.

The surviving object, a stanchion from the flight support equipment used to secure the batteries to the cargo pallet, is composed of the metal alloy Inconel. It measures 4 inches in height and 1.6 inches in diameter, and weighs 1.6 pounds. The ISS is conducting further investigations to understand how this piece endured the re-entry process. NASA remains committed to reducing the risks associated with operations in low-Earth orbit.

A strange, cylindrical object slammed into the roof of a house in Naples, Florida, last month, tearing through two floors and nearly hitting a person inside. The house's owner is searching for who is responsible and suspects that the debris came from the International Space Station.

A March 7 safety bulletin from the European Space Agency (ESA) warned that nine spent batteries from the ISS totaling 2.6 metric tons – over 5,700 pounds – would enter the atmosphere the following day. The junk had circled the Earth since January 2021 in a decaying orbit.

Estimated impact zone (European Space Agency)

Unsurprisingly, most of the estimated path fell over the ocean. However, it also covered parts of Mexico, Florida, Central Europe, and the Middle East. Although the agency predicted that some bits would survive reentry, it still rated the probability of injuries as "very low."

After multiple revisions, the final estimated impact window was between 18:30 and 20:08 UTC. Astronomer Jonathan McDowell reported a 19:29 UTC impact between the Gulf of Mexico and Cuba. However, Naples resident Alejandro Otero responded to McDowell with photos of a metal cylinder that crashed through his roof and two floors that day. Otero wasn't home at the time, but his son was.

Fortunately, no one was hurt, but the incident was too close for comfort. Otero's Nest camera recorded the sound of the impact at 19:34 UTC – within the ESA's window and only five minutes after McDowell's time. Authorities haven't confirmed that the object came from the ISS. This incident marks the second time within a few weeks that the ESA reported an uncontrolled re-entry.

In February, officials confirmed the fall of a satellite that had been in a slowly decaying orbit since 2011. Although the risk of damage or injury from space debris isn't zero, returning it to Earth is safer than leaving it in space, where it could create more space junk and potentially endanger future space travel. Otero thinks space agencies should do more to ensure that debris completely disintegrates in the atmosphere.

Permalink to story:

 
Can you sue for damages if it hit your home? Hard to believe insurance would cover this.
Many countries insure or self insure regarding their space debris impacting someone/thing on earth. So hopefully you don’t need to sue.

But if the perpetrator is russia or the like, possibly not, and even if you are successful launching a multi million dollar international court case, and win. Trying to force them to pay is difficult to say the least.
 
If NASA refused to pay, I hope the homeowners insurance company & the homeowner take them to court.
 
But if the perpetrator is russia or the like, possibly not, and even if you are successful launching a multi million dollar international court case, and win. Trying to force them to pay is difficult to say the least.
Actually, both Russia and the United States are signatory to the 1972 treaty "Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects", which specifies they WILL assume all liability from such damage. And when a Soviet Kosmos satellite spread radioactive debris in Canada in 1978, the cleanup fee was paid by the USSR.
 
Actually, both Russia and the United States are signatory to the 1972 treaty "Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects", which specifies they WILL assume all liability from such damage. And when a Soviet Kosmos satellite spread radioactive debris in Canada in 1978, the cleanup fee was paid by the USSR.

Alas Putin would never pay a cent if this happened under his dictatorship. The USSR under Gorbachev and Yeltsin was a reasonably sane and rational place.
 
Alas Putin would never pay a cent if this happened under his dictatorship. The USSR under Gorbachev and Yeltsin was a reasonably sane and rational place.
Spoken by someone who's never been within 2,000 km of the region. There was no "USSR under Yeltsin", and the USSR under Brezhnev -- when this event actually did occur -- was a considerably less free and more repressive system than exists in Russia today.
 
Spoken by someone who's never been within 2,000 km of the region. There was no "USSR under Yeltsin", and the USSR under Brezhnev -- when this event actually did occur -- was a considerably less free and more repressive system than exists in Russia today.
I think he was concentrating on the fact that the current leader of Russia is in near open warfare with the west and any payment would be seen as weakness.
 
Spoken by someone who's never been within 2,000 km of the region. There was no "USSR under Yeltsin", and the USSR under Brezhnev -- when this event actually did occur -- was a considerably less free and more repressive system than exists in Russia today.

Yep Yeltsin rounded all opposition and executed them, shut down all independent media outlets, also invaded nearby countries, regularly arrested dissidents. Yeltsin may have been a buffoon but he was no pyschotic despot.
Sounds like you haven't been within 3 light years of earth.
 
Yep Yeltsin rounded all opposition and executed them, shut down all independent media outlets, also invaded nearby countries, regularly arrested dissidents.
Sounds like you're describing Zelensky -- except for the invasion bit. As for that, tell me again why the US attacked Serbia, Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, Lebanon, Yemen, Libya, Panama, and Grenada?
 
Back