TechSpot

Android 52% faster than iPhone in browsing speed

By Emil
Mar 17, 2011
Post New Reply
  1. Update (10:45pm): As pointed out by our readers' comments, there seems to be an inherent flaw to the way iPhones were benchmarked. Apple claims the embedded browser environment that was used for this test doesn't have all of the Mobile Safari's performance optimizations that include JavaScript, asynchronous page-loading and HTML5 caching.

    Read the whole story
     
  2. Rick

    Rick TechSpot Staff Posts: 6,305   +52 Staff Member

    The numbers from this 'study' appear to be completely unreliable. Appreciatively, Blaze points this out (I really believe they intended this to be as fair as possible). Don't take my word for it though:

    I don't trust Apple's input, but for any developer who hypothesizes that their own embedded browser [even though it uses Safari's renderer] is a fair substitute for an empirical study... well, they do not understand the concept of minimizing variables.

    I appreciate what they were trying to do here but the reality is they did it wrong and even then, the difference was minimal so this is hardly worthy of the sensational headlines I've been seeing everywhere (not aimed at TS, of course).
     
  3. mosu

    mosu TS Enthusiast Posts: 309   +9

    quote:"The fact that Android beat iPhone by such a large margin was not expected". Maybe by you! I used both and came to a really close conclusion.And by the way, hardware counts.
     
  4. Leeky

    Leeky TS Evangelist Posts: 4,378   +99

    I have to say my experiences of my iPhone 3GS 8GB vs. my HTC Desire (both on the same network) are the HTC is considerably faster at anything using a network connection.

    I can't speak for the new iPhone4 though, but mine did run iOS4.2 I believe before I last packed it up and put it away.
     
  5. negroplasty

    negroplasty TS Maniac Posts: 537   +12

    My Nexus One on 2.3.3 is lightning fast, I don't need a study to tell me that, nor an Apply fanboy to tell me otherwise.. It is what it is.
     
  6. NeoFryBoy

    NeoFryBoy TS Rookie Posts: 72

    I like how they didn't give actual time measurements. Clearly there are flaws here.
     
  7. Will_m

    Will_m TS Enthusiast Posts: 102

    My HTC desire beat my friends iphone 4 over wi-fi 4/5 times and the 1 was only lost by a fraction of a second, so I can't see this being wrong really.
     
  8. Zecias

    Zecias TS Booster Posts: 202

    for those of you saying your android phones are much faster than the iphone
    the speed difference may be due to your phones having superior hardware and very little to do with the browser; It really isn't a valid way of testing the speed of the browser. This may have also been the case with the study. screen resolution might have also played a role in the speed.
    just something to think about.
    in any case, take the study with a grain of salt.
     
  9. bonniesmith

    bonniesmith TS Rookie Posts: 40

    Android is faster in general, I have both device and that's fact.
     
  10. Leeky

    Leeky TS Evangelist Posts: 4,378   +99

    I don't know about others, but I was reflecting on my actual experiences of using both devices.

    Whether Android features far superior drivers or not, it is faster. Faster is faster, period.

    Though I have to say its somewhat surprising when you consider the closed loop of driver requirements for iPhone hardware - its not like they have a 100 different setups (and counting) to deal with. They only need to consider ability to read bigger memory in the iOS, everything (to my knowledge) remains the same on each different iPhone type.
     
  11. Rick

    Rick TechSpot Staff Posts: 6,305   +52 Staff Member

    Drivers?
     
     
  12. Leeky

    Leeky TS Evangelist Posts: 4,378   +99

    I would imagine that they use pretty similar network hardware, my point being that maybe the difference is down to the drivers built to allow its use in the OS of each device.

    I also made note of the fact you would usually consider it to be the other way around. With Apple developing software to suit certain hardware and the subsequent control they exhibit on it, you would expect Apple to be able to provide a considerably better OS given the set hardware.

    Android on the other hand has to contend with tens of different designs, hardware and controllers - and work perfectly for each of them.

    It should be easy to perfect things when you have only one unit to design, build and make a success.
     
  13. MrAnderson

    MrAnderson TS Maniac Posts: 488   +10

    Test will always be imperfect. It might be more valid to do a study on perceived speed.

    That is what seems to matter more since you are running 2 different OS on different hardware.

    If Google took an iOS device and ported Android and browser to function on it and said this is the best we can do test away? and of course provided a tool to log and measure page loads? then apple provide a tool also log and measure page loads in safari? both with and without the optimization features on and off could we really get close to some answers.

    But perceived speed is probably really more important because when people read these articles, we are thinking about our experience with the browser and our satisfaction with or perception of being able to consume the content loading in the browser?

    This is way more difficult to pin down when running benchmarks for frames per second and JavaScript speed tests.
     


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.