TechSpot

Connecting to 2 ISPs at once

By Vehementi
Jul 21, 2002
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. I've been thinking about this for a while now.

    It involves two modems, two phone lines, and two ISPs. Right now I just need another modem, then I can try it :D
    I know it's possible...All I haven't worked out is a program to balance the load between the two. MYOB tells me it's built into XP, but I'm looking for a 3rd party program for ME.
    Has anyone done this? I'd like some insight :D
     
  2. StormBringer

    StormBringer TS Rookie Posts: 2,871

    I've never seen it done quite that way before. I do know that it is possible to multi-link, but that is done with the same ISP usually. It seems what you want to do should be possible because some old cable and SAT systems used a similar method because you had to have a separate ISP for upload, as you could only download from from the other modem.
     
  3. Rick

    Rick TechSpot Staff Posts: 6,304   +52 Staff Member

    I've done what you are talking about, including someting slightly different (and possibly what you mean to do) called "modem bonding".. Or multi-link.. It's far better than what you've mentioned.. I will explain.

    Multi-link: Two phonelines, two modems, two ISP accounts on the same ISP that supports MLP connections.

    Multi PPP: Two phonelines, two modems, two ISP accounts on seperate ISPs or a single ISP that does not support multi-link connections.


    What you are talking about is not MLP (mulitlink), but some sort of dual PPP dial-up connection. This is impossible for Windows XP to do natively, as well as all other Windows versions. You will need a 3rd party program. Windows XP and 2000 can multi-link though.. There are clear advantages in mulitlink over multi PPP, but I'll get to that later.

    Unfortunately, multi-PPP works very badly. Unlike multi-link, the connections are never negotiated to work as a single connection, so you cannot download things twice as fast. Instead, you can download two things, each at normal speed. And then it varies on the efficiency of the program you are using to negotiate your multi PPP connection.

    For example, if you usually get 5kb/sec download speeds using a single modem, then multi-PPP would allow you to download two files at 5kb/sec total. However, if you are downloading one file, you will only see 5kb/sec. This is theoretical speed too... Your actual speed will vary greatly depending on the program you are using to multi-PPP.

    For browsing the web, multi-PPP is not any faster. For downloading files, it seemed to be eactly the same speed as usual (Under 5kb/sec). Downloading two files however, I could get a max transfer rate of about 30% higher than I usually got... So instead of 4.7k/sec, I got about 6.5kb/sec. Keep in mind this is TOTAL for two files at the same time. It makes no difference for downloading only one file or the download speed of the files individually. If I was downloading only one file, I only got 4.7kb, which is my usual max.

    Comparing this to multi-link, multi-PPP is a waste of money (for the extra account, modem and phoneline). With multi-link, I was getting just under 10kb/sec for file downloads and pages loaded really fast... It almost felt like broadband. ;)

    However, to use multi-link, your ISP must support it. If there is an alternative, then modem bonding is rediculously expensive. An extra phoneline and ISP account more than double what you may be paying already, for not a whole lot more speed. DSL and cable (if available) are far better options. You may even want to consider satellite if you are willing to spend that much money.

    If you decide to use two modems, use multi-link instead of multi-PPP. It's much better. In summary...

    -----------------------------------
    Multi-link advantages:
    - Doubles your bandwith for everything.
    - Native support on Windows 2000 and Windows XP

    Multi-link disadvantages:
    - Requires special ISP support
    ------------------------------------

    Multi PPP advantages:
    - Well, it works on some level I guess.
    - Requires no special ISP support and may be used on 2 different ISPs. Multi-link can only be done using two accounts on a single ISP.

    Multi PPP disadvantages:
    - Just as slow as normal, except when downloading two files at once
    - Under no circumstances is it ever as fast as multi-link.
    - Not supported by any Windows operating systems. You will need a 3rd party program which may cost you some cash.
    -----------------------------------
     
  4. Vehementi

    Vehementi TechSpot Paladin Topic Starter Posts: 3,199

    You're the man Rick

    I have 2 ISPs, one's 56k and the other, 28k. Both of no charge to me.

    Congratulations Rick you have eliminated every shred of my curiousity on the subject. :D Thanks
     
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...


Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.