Google reportedly asks Samsung to dial back its custom Android UI and homegrown apps

  1. When Samsung debuted its new Magazine UX user interface at CES earlier this month, Google was reportedly displeased by it because the new UI, which looked like a mix of Flipboard and Microsoft's Metro, was a radical departure from the...

    Read more
  2. BMfan

    BMfan TechSpot Guru Posts: 470   +47

    Great,then I wouldn't need a custom kernel on my S4 to get rid of half the rubbish that Samsung puts on.
    wastedkill and NimbusTLD like this.
  3. treeski

    treeski TechSpot Guru Posts: 867   +128

    Interesting... Isn't one of the draws to Android (from OEM perspective) the ability to really differentiate from competitors?
  4. Yes, But remember that they are paying nothing to google for use of the OS. Google has a right to even demand that they dont radically change their product for resell. And frankly, Thank GOD. The Galaxy phones are usually the best, but because of the crap they add to it, I usually have to go with the Nexus phones. Iv been using Android since the G1. And had the GS1 from Samsung. I never understood why they changed the UI in the first place.

    If it aint broke, DONT FIX IT!
    H3llion likes this.
  5. GeforcerFX

    GeforcerFX TechSpot Booster Posts: 303   +43

    Google stills wants the OS to look and operate nearly the same. They want it easy for android users to switch to different handset manufacturers.
    MilwaukeeMike and H3llion like this.
  6. If Samsung makes it look like the Metro UI, they will be the big loser.
  7. treeski

    treeski TechSpot Guru Posts: 867   +128

    Doubtful. Galaxy is already an extremely well known brand, and people will buy it at this point because it's what they're familiar with.
  8. MilwaukeeMike

    MilwaukeeMike TechSpot Evangelist Posts: 2,011   +683

    This. Samsung has a unique UI across their devices and part of the reason is to keep their customers. People won't want to buy an HTC or LG next time if they feel they have to learn their phone all over again. I'm glad Samsung is changing some things though, that Touchwiz UI makes their gadgets look like toys.
  9. I really hope that don't get rid of WatchON. I use it for my tv everyday. To my knowledge google doesn't have an app that does the same thing with the tv controls.
  10. lipe123

    lipe123 TechSpot Guru Posts: 408   +73

    Apart from the crap like chaton and flipboard etc that they force on the phone I don't see why Google wants to force people to have the same UI.

    The whole appeal of android is that its not an iphone where everyone has the same boring thing and no one is allowed to change the look and feel of it.
    If you give the OS away as open source then you can't really complain when there was changes made to it.
  11. UI should be optional. In most cases I am forced to root my devices and flash clean room. Also all this extra functions and apps should be possible to turn off. My new Xperia Z ultra is coming with services for Facebook and Twitter build into the rom. WTH is that. I don't use any of that and I don't like even having disabled services for that crap. I was happy enough to have option to instal Google Play Edition for my device. Clean rom and I can install whatever I need.
     
  12. Archean

    Archean TechSpot Paladin Posts: 6,034   +70

    At best this arrangement will serve as slowing down Samsung's search for diversifying its options. Current arrangement means Samsung makes one time profit on unit sale, and Google makes all the rest through their services (e.g. search/adds) for the rest of product's life cycle. Which isn't good business for Samsung in the long run.

    So sometime in not so distant future, when selling just hardware will no longer be as much profitable proposition as it may be today, Samsung will have to reconsider its position and come up with a solution which can help it maximize its profitability. That would mean either Google will have to relent and share their services profits with OEMs or OEMs offering their own alternative services by ditching Google.
  13. hellokitty[hk]

    hellokitty[hk] I'm a TechSpot Evangelist Posts: 4,317   +117

    Please just have light snappy OSs.
  14. Mukarram

    Mukarram Newcomer, in training

    Im gonna go against the grain here; I actually like most of the samsung features and some of the software.


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.