Home › News › Industry News
Microsoft wins patent case appeal, overturns $388M fine
Uniloc claims it had demonstrated its software to Microsoft in 1993, but that instead of licensing it Redmond went on to develop an almost identical product. Microsoft has consistently claimed it used a different activation method, and furthermore argues that Uniloc's patent is invalid because the technique was obvious.
This is the third ruling in the Uniloc-Microsoft patent dispute and basically puts the companies back were they started six years ago. Microsoft originally won a summary judgment on the dispute in 2007, but Uniloc appealed that decision which resulted in the now nullified $388 million award. Uniloc can appeal the current verdict and, if it wins, Microsoft would have the right to a new trial.
The Uniloc case is just one of two major patent battles Microsoft is currently facing. They are also being hounded by a lawsuit filed against them by Canadian software maker i4i to the tune of $200 million, which centers on Microsoft's use of custom XML tags in Word 2003 and Word 2007.
Related Stories
User Comments (4)
Post a comment|
raybay
on September 30, 2009 2:19 PM |
The power of money... and the ability to hire enough lawyers skilled in the inside outs of software design... But who is going to pay the Uniloc attorneys. |
|
captaincranky
on September 30, 2009 3:13 PM |
When you have as much clout (money) as M$, doesn't it seem more cost effective to "eliminate the middle man" so to speak, and just buy the appeals Court? Although, I wonder how many more lawyers they'll be able to afford with the revenues from Windows 7. Scary thought, no? |
|
TorturedChaos
on September 30, 2009 3:38 PM |
captaincranky said: When you have as much clout (money) as M$, doesn't it seem more cost effective to "eliminate the middle man" so to speak, and just buy the appeals Court?? I laugh when I read that, then got a little scared.... |
|
Guest
on October 1, 2009 1:56 AM |
How much did Microsoft pay the judge ? |
Most Popular
| Trending | Featured |
-
iOS 5.1.1 untethered jailbreak tool released, supports 4S, iPad 3
-
After five days, Facebook ranks as worst IPO flop of the decade
-
Rumor: Windows 8 RC will launch June 1, will ship with Adobe Flash
-
Rumor: AMD "Piledriver" FX CPU production to begin Q3 2012
-
Is Apple's USB wall adapter really worth $29?
Editors' Tablet Picks
Subscribe to TechSpot
Get free exclusive content, learn about new features and tech breaking news.