Does anyone know of one that wouldn't rename all the files you want recovered?

The one I'm using right now is renaming all my files to "Recovered_XXX_XXX"

What program are you using right now?

Have you ever tried "Restoration"?
http://www.snapfiles.com/get/restoration.html

Also, if you are willing to pay $40 or so you can get some professional software; just thought I'd mention that.