TechSpot

AT&T: Windows Phone is not selling well, yet

By Emil
Jun 7, 2011
Post New Reply
  1. AT&T Mobility CEO Ralph de la Vega recently took the time to do an interview with All Things Digital. While he answered various questions about the mobile industry, his comments…

    Read the whole story
     
  2. stewi0001

    stewi0001 TS Evangelist Posts: 1,181   +528

    The Apple lovers got their iPhones and mostly everybody else is going with the Droid (myself included when the time comes for a new phone)

    I figure that their marketshare is only going to be people that might love Microsoft and people who have been turned off from the iPhone and the Driod.

    So ya low sales are not surprising right now.
     
  3. Trillionsin

    Trillionsin TS Evangelist Posts: 1,315   +133

    maybe if someone around me got one and I could check it out... this is why i got an iPhone, then when a coworked got an Andriod phone, I switched over to that. I bet that the Microsoft phone cant do anything near what the iPhone and Andriod phones can do because of all the developers and being able to jailbreak or root the device. Not saying its not possible with microsoft's new phone, but that simply put if its not as popular... well, it's not going to be as popular. haha
     
  4. Archean

    Archean TechSpot Paladin Posts: 5,682   +86

    Well trillion, as you said your self that you haven't checked WP first hand, so to say the least everyone in my 'geek circle' who happen to have a chance to play with WP phone, prefer it over android and well iphone is a no go anyway. I think one area where Microsoft should look into is encouraging its partners to offer better hardware on these devices and bring that update out on-time, about the earlier argument e.g. Omnia 7 have the ingredients but the looks of the phone are ..... just a turn off. When it come to stability Android is near rubbish to say the least (mainly because everyone is doing their own thing with it), even my old WinMo Omnia was miles ahead in this area, it never crashed in about 3 years till I gave it away. Before that I had Tytn II same story no instability, even my last E series Nokia had much better stability/battery life etc. So considering my own experience, I don't recommend anyone buying an android phone, and so far I observed that this results in people either buying E series phones or WP7, and usually are happier with the choices.
     
  5. yRaz

    yRaz TS Evangelist Posts: 1,897   +940

    Going to have to say I was turned off by Android and iPhone. What turned me off about Android was that to many manufacturers wanted to do their own thing with the GUI and preload bloatware. No reason to get into why I didn't want an iPhone.

    Right now I see Android as being desirable just because it's popular. It doesn't have much to offer as far as security(business users) and it does not make good use of the hardware. I still think that android tried to model a lot of it's operating system after iOS.

    I really love my windows phone and I'm not a Mircosoft fan boy. I'd buy it again in a heartbeat, hopefully the mango update will fix just about every bug it has. Their aren't really bugs, just features that I wish it had or something should work in a different way. I had some issues when I first got my phone with freezing but that was all fixed in the first update. I can't wait to see what WP7 really has to offer in the 7.1 update
     
  6. Archean

    Archean TechSpot Paladin Posts: 5,682   +86

    +1 about the business user yRaz, e.g. there is a reason every one else has failed to break into corporate sector when it comes to OS/Productivity software. Such users want stability, stability and stability x security^3. So on these counts having extensively tried DHD and owned SGS, Android is simply a no go just as iphone. I came very close to buying HD7 (but I was put off by its sluggish refresh rate) and Omnia (its ugly looks just doesn't cut it); so I am hoping some of the upcoming WP phones will have competitive hardware and other design elements ...
     
  7. The best Android phone is the Samsung Galaxy S I and II, not the Droid. So the comment about "It's either iPhone or the Droid" makes no sense. Once the Galaxy S II launches stateside, it will mop the floor with Android competition.

    Also, regarding the comments that business users do not use iPhones or Android phones, that's probably because you work for 40+ year old bosses who are very conservative. Perhaps in the financial sector (such as banking) where conservatism and creativity are inversely related. However, if you work for a cool firm, then lots of their employees will use iPhones and Android phones. Even engineers in the automotive firms are starting to use iPhones. So please don't try to pretend here that your obsolete 2.4 inch blackberry with outdated OS is the God's gift to security. In fact, most security breaches and intellectual property theft occur as a result of you losing your work laptop, not some sophisticated over the air hack.
     
  8. aj_the_kidd

    aj_the_kidd TS Rookie Posts: 555

    Its pretty awesome and no lag, plus GPS actually works. Before getting the SGS2, i was thinking about getting a windows phone, but they are no quite to the point where i want them to be yet
     
  9. Archean

    Archean TechSpot Paladin Posts: 5,682   +86

    @Guest
    In Business environment there is a case for avoiding Android because of inherent issue of it being modified to suite manufacturer's taste. Hence the changes they make/or UI they slap on top of it can cause considerable stability issues. For example, my Galaxy S would crash or lag for no apparent reason, whenever it feels like doing it. I felt pretty similar about DHD as well, but may be I was expecting bit too much from it.
     
  10. "if you work for a cool firm"

    Working for a cool or uncool firm or however old someone is has nothing to do with it, it has to do with being able to properly secure a phone, to meet established company "security" standards.

    Both andoid and iphone have deployment tools to help manage this, and you can custom order phones without bloat (talk to business sales). The key here is even more granular control and OTA ability to make changes in corporate-assigned phones. Think active directory,.. but for phones. This is why Blackberry is popular in the corporate sector (cool/uncool or old/young boss or whatever). Because you can fine tune and lock down many aspects of the phone. The key here is how well Windows phone will take advantage if this. I've played with both Android and Apple phones and both are cool. But the one that intrigued me the most was the windows phone; if because I'm a heavy onenote, msoffice, and outlook user. And being able to have phone with deep hooks in these apps would help with my workload lifestyle.

    I'm just glad we have many platforms to choose from. It would be very boring if there were only 1 or 2. Choice is great
     

Similar Topics

Add New Comment

You need to be a member to leave a comment. Join thousands of tech enthusiasts and participate.
TechSpot Account You may also...