Looks like this benchmark mess is still ongoing. I don't think it will ever end as long as there is competiton between these two companies. [H]ardOcp has a rereview of a review they did, in which they say ATi openly disagrees with. If you don't feel like reading the whole thing, go to the last page, the conclusion, and it gives a pretty good summary of what they found. It looks pretty inconclusive to me, to close to really call any real difference between the two.