TechSpot

HTC loses to Apple, several Android phones banned in the U.S.

By Rick
Dec 21, 2011
Post New Reply
  1. The U.S. International Trade Commission finally issued its decision on a patent dispute between Apple and HTC. The determination states that several of the manufacturer's Android-based handsets will be banned…

    Read the whole story
     
  2. The Nexus One was an HTC phone, not Samsung. Regardless, this is a sad day to be sure.
     
  3. Go Apple, GO GO APPLE! Your place is over the android phones. They are weak and slow!
     
  4. If there is such thing as "Divine Justice" I assure you that Apple and all those at Apple responsible for all the misery they cause in the IT&C and mobile phones&tablets sector, will pay for it, all that you do one day will backfires at you Apple.
    Apple is an abomination to this world and they should be exterminated.
     
  5. Steve

    Steve TechSpot Staff Posts: 1,463   +508 Staff Member

    Not sure about divine justice but I would say if it does it would not apply in this case, it’s conquered by blind fanboyism.
     
  6. mario

    mario Ex-TS Developer Posts: 399   +17

    Blind fanboyism, more like blind anti-fanboyism.

    Apple changed the way smartphones work, created the tablet market and redefined what a notebook should be. Recognize, then buy whatever you want.
     
  7. But how much rotten apples a fanboy can eat before going sick ? LOL
     
  8. I don't know...if you copy and steal you pay for it! Simple as that! Doesn't matter which company you are!
     
  9. Wait a moment since Apple wasn't a telecommunication company like Motorola, Nokia, and others they had no history, experience or any other research&development in the field of mobile phones, what they did in 2007 with their first mobile phone released aka iPhone was to copy and steal all the technology that others like Motorola, Nokia&CO have invented and developed through decades before Apple was ever thinking on producing a mobile phone.
    So look who stole all that mobile phone technology in the first place, Apple stole it.
     
  10. The ITC's decision favors the Apple believers... yet this could carry a dangerous precedent towards the developing future... if you can patent stuff the way Apple does , then the outline of the future will be very Apple-like coloured...
    Believe me, eventually Apple will run out of bright ideas and the rest of the developing community couldn't be bothered anymore...

    The patent-war should come to an end before the End-User choice and experience is determined by just 1 manufacturer.

    Diversity is what we need, so imho the ITC should be overruled by some judge that has a clear view on what technology could bring us in the future.

    ... Are you sure all of you want to drive grey cars and all wear the same grey clothes, because this is what we are working on with this whole patent bullshit.
     
  11. Ranger1st

    Ranger1st TS Enthusiast Posts: 275   +77

    US protectionism is action, The tablet computer as apple saw it is a direct copy of Kubrick's 2001 space odyssey prop. The iphone was a simple evolution that if apple hadn't made there were many others out there that would have. I find their shotgun lawsuits and patent trolling to also be very distasteful. not a company i would ever support.
     
     
  12. hahahanoobs

    hahahanoobs TS Maniac Posts: 1,009   +103

    HTC don't seem worried, so neither am I. HTC is a powerhouse and they will get through this. Cook must of been forced at gunpoint to continue the Android hate. I do feel sorry for Apple though. Before Jobs passed away I wanted future iPhones to fade into the sunset... now I just hate them outright.
     
  13. inventix1136

    inventix1136 TS Rookie Posts: 85   +14

    Patents were heralded as an aid in innovation and yet here we are with Apple patenting an idea that many developers already done in the 1990's via Perl scripts and parsing of screen data.

    Thank god our patent system was not around in the caveman's time otherwise all of us would still be waiting for lightning strikes to get fire due to the patent for original fire, in essence killing all innovation...
     
  14. Butch

    Butch TS Enthusiast Posts: 112

    First let me preface by saying I really like HTC. I have owned more than one of their phones, but the bottom line is that if HTC (or any other company) held those patents they would do the same thing. Its unfortunate but true. I don't think it's fair to say that Apple is evil because of this kind of stuff. They just happen to own certain patents. Now whether Apple actually developed the technology in question or purchased it, or stole it is another discussion. Also, before you flame me, I am NOT a Apple fanboy. Just a realist...
     
  15. p51d007

    p51d007 TS Booster Posts: 350   +54

    I understand needing to protect your "IP", but, Apple is receiving a lot of bad press about their way of going after copyright claims. It makes Apple look like they can't beat "android" with their devices without trying to get the droid style phones banned. Innovation use to be Apple's strong suit, but the iPhone 4S didn't really "innovate". Except for iOS5, redesigned antenna (fail on the 4), it's just a warmed over 4. If 5 doesn't "wow" the non rabid iPhone fan, Apples days of "leader" might be a thing of the past. The era of Steve "I can't do anything wrong" Jobs could be over, which is bad for the entire industry. Before the iPhone came along, the "cool" phone was a Razr...look how far it has come.
     
  16. As long as we have a humanity so daft as not to recognize the all pervasive interdependence then we will continue in this massive nonsensical struggle to possess creation. At worst it will drive us to the brink of extinction just as we have already driven so many other life forms and at best it will leave this planet a misery where the dead will pity the living.

    Do not be so foolish as to trade long-term happiness for fly-by-night rectangular blinkers that go "ping".
     
  17. emmzo

    emmzo TS Enthusiast Posts: 71

    Well, Apple is the no.1 US company so they have to find ways of protecting it from powerful asian competitors. There`s no philosophical debate here on patents or other potential means of achieving its goals, just follow the money imho. After all it`s a war out there for controlling a huge market and unfortunately the causalities are us, the customers.
     
  18. Im sure steve jobs left some sort of "if i die tomorrow" agenda to cover a course of a few years, once that runs out, appletonians everywhere will be scrambling like chickens with no heads.
     
  19. Det

    Det TS Rookie Posts: 84

    You are so silly.
     
  20. Det

    Det TS Rookie Posts: 84

    Nobody's flaming you. That's a good point of view.

    It just seems that HTC won't have a big job dealing with these changes so who cares - especially if this really only concerns Android 1.6-2.2.
     
  21. Apple and all your Fanboy ****** can rejoice. You are creating a monopolistic environment and following blindly just like North Korea. I'm sick of your *****ic comments about who is better and who came out with what. All of this is supposed to help us, humans. And being communist about your devices, your software, and your company is not going to help out anyone. Eventually people will see you for the company you really are. Steve Jobs goes down the same year as Kim Jong il? I hope they share a nice glass of "I'm a lil b.i.t.c.h who used people my entire life and my legacy is to try to slow our technological advancement." Kudos dog. I hope the both of you live in everlasting misery.
     
  22. isamuelson

    isamuelson TS Rookie Posts: 96

    How the hell do you patent a hyperlink? Apple didn't invent it. Does this mean ANY hyperlink is now a patent of Apple? Come on. This is ridiculous. What did Apple slip under the table to get this stupid, *****ic ruling?

    This keeps up, forget having choices, people. If Apple corners the market and forces everyone else out, you won't have a choice.

    How many of these same Apple fanboys were so dead-set against Microsoft and wanting them to go down as well and wanted Apple to be the #1? It's amazing how they cheer against the competition, yet when their company does exactly what they are against, they cheer for it. What lemmings.

    Hopefully, this can get overturned somewhere because as small and minute as it might seem, it could have serious repercussions in the long run that affect everyone's choices: mainly, reducing them.
     
  23. I think most of the so called Apple fanboys that post pro Apple messages across the web are in fact Apple employes and web bots that scan the web searching for latest Apple news and where they find one they eagerly post a pro Apple message on that page in order to trick the consumers to buy an Apple toy instead.
     
  24. Now I may be completely wrong here, as I don't have time or inclination to look up the facts, but hasn't programs such as Skype had the ability to detect phone numbers in text and highlight them with an action for ages? Way before the iphone was invented? How did Apple manage to patent something that was already invented?
     
  25. Stealing someone elses idea previously implemented only follows the same greedy idiocy also seen in the fact that someone can now obtain a copyright to a musical piece penned in the 1800's. Fairness, integrity, and ethics only seem to appear in the dictionary.

    Just another reason to advise against supporting Apple products.
     


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.