Is this a good deal?

deal 1:
I bought a used 2005 model Emachine in early 2006.

- AMD Athlon64 3200+ winchester
- 160gb hdd 7200rpm, 2mb cache (slow)
- 512mb ram
- x700pro pci-express
- 300watt bestec psu (fried after a month)
- 15 inch LCD emachine monitor (put face 1 inch see tiny lines across screen)
- mouse+keyboard
- basic 2 piece speaker
- windows xp home

for 480.00 usd grand total. good or bad deal? (for a pre-build)


deal 2:
bought refurbish sapphire X850 XT pci-express back in november 2006. sealed original box set, everything included, smell so fresh and so clean, looks like never been used. for 111.111 usd grand total. is it a good deal for the time I bought it? nov 2006? I mostly play mmos.

Looks like a pretty bad deal to me considering the crap quality of the Emachines. I bought a Dell E510 in November 2006 with a 7600GT, 1 GB of ram, and 250Gigs for about the same amount of money.

#1. bad deal
#2. fair deal