also @ TechSpot: Leaked next generation iPhone casing photos validate multiple rumors

TechSpot

Mac or PC for college?

Discussion in 'The Alternative OS' started by bkouns001, Jun 9, 2008.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. bkouns001 Newcomer, in training

    What great advice I got, thanks all. Dell it is, we will check with the school especially since it is in Dell's home town, Austin, TX.

    I would have gone with the Mac but after showing him all the suggestions I had received, he decided that the PC was a better choice for him. He has enough adjusting ahead of him without adding the complication of a new computer system.

    I did chuckle however that you all nixed the IBM. I have had a Thinkpad for almost 15 years with absolutely no problems and I love it. But as my g'son says, its a machine for business people and older folks, of course, he got that from Consumer Report, lol....which by the way, rates it number one in many areas.

    Thanks again all.
  2. SNGX1275 TechSpot Special Forces

    The 2.4Ghz Macbooks do use the Penryn. Link1, Link2, Link3

    It is really no harder than installing Windows on a PC, there is just an additional step of creating a partition for it first on the Mac end. Apple even provides an extremely detailed step by step instructions on how to do it.

    If you buy more RAM when you order it you get raped on the price. It is FAR cheaper to buy the RAM yourself from someone else and then install it. Even if you hire someone to install the RAM for you it will still likely be cheaper.

    So I think the Macbook is by far the "better value for the money". Penryn processor, better wireless, lighter weight, ability to run Mac OS X, Linux, Windows XP, Windows Vista. Insanely easy access to HD and RAM for upgrades (that don't void your warranty), and several other little things.
  3. think_guru Newcomer, in training

    I just have to throw in my support for IBM here, and raise some points that might be helpful to consider. First, as we all know, they are very solid and well designed machines. I've experience using a Thinkpad, and their combo of reliability + great keyboard makes them a superb choice for students. Also, the newer T61's feature a roll cage, which can be handy because it will prevent the screen from being damaged incase the machine gets crushed by school books in your bag (which often happens)!

    In terms of economics, it looks like Lenovo is really trying to cut their price. Additionally, their reputation for durability seems to afford Thinkpads a greater resale value, which can be handy when it comes time to upgrade.

    Those are just some of my thoughts. However, I when it comes down to it, you are choosing amongst a number of great machines, so it's mainly just a personal preference. From what I can see the Dell XPS offers top-notch performance, and the extended customization options are nice as well, so I don't see how you can go wrong. Congrats on your choice!
  4. Ph30nIX Newcomer, in training

    Dell is notorious for shocking service, in particular once your warranty is out. They use the same crappy motherboards in their more expensive systems which are from their cheaper systems. If you buy a dell, mak esure you get an extended warranty on it!!

    HP are good, and I can vouch for their services. I once had one that broke 3 times in the 5 years of using it, and it was serviced free of charge and some parts replaced with better ones.

    However, the software side of HP is a bit annoying.

    From Dell and Mac, I'd almost certainly go the Mac route, they are easy to use, and effectively ***** proof.
  5. bkouns001 Newcomer, in training

    Thanks for your input; the deal is done, Dell it is, with an extended warranty.

    I am glad that you have had success with HP, my only reference point was Consumer Reports and some pretty angry people at The Squeaky Wheel; nothing at Squeaky about Dell but several about HP.

    LOL, sounds like maybe I should get a Mac.
  6. LNCPapa TS Special Forces

    Glad you were able to make a decision - just keep in mind that you're mostly going to hear from people with bad to say. Most people who are happy just don't say anything. I actually own a couple of Mac laptops and a Dell and if I were to spend my own money on a laptop for myself it would be a Dell - but XPS series.
  7. kenpachi Newcomer, in training

    Stick with a PC laptop they are a lot more affordable
  8. Ty-Man Newcomer, in training

    Yes, it can ba painful decision, eh?
    Mac's are great in their simplicity and creativity
    while PC's are good for school work and such.
    But I have a Mac and a Dell, and it is no more difficult to owrk microsoft word, or powerpoint on the Mac than the Dell.
    But i would much much rather have a dell than an HP.
    they are slow, and they stink :l
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.