TechSpot

RIAA: ISPs to implement anti-piracy measures by July 12

By Jos
Mar 15, 2012
Post New Reply
  1. Internet service providers are set to launch a new anti-piracy scheme this summer designed to alert and eventually punish suspected copyright infringers. The new policy was unveiled last year when…

    Read the whole story
  2. Money can obviously buy anything. It is absolutely absurd that they are now determined to undermine the human rights of its population. Makes me embarrassed to be part of the human race.

    This sis absolutely ridiculous and absurd; surely you are joking Mr. Feyman.

    RIAA is complete sh!t. A bunch of inhumane and greedy me gustas; do they even have a heart beat?

    Maybe it is about time Shepard came and went medieval on their rumps.

    Loved the ending of Mass Effect 3 by the way! I thought it was beautiful!
  3. H3llion

    H3llion TechSpot Paladin Posts: 968   +99

    Sounds fair.

    As long as you send Warnings and after X strikes you're busted then I think that is a fair deal.

    *cough* VPN + Peerblock ;)
  4. Someone will take this to court. IP Address evidence has been disallowed in court cases prior to this. If all they have is an IP address, they may have a very hard time standing on legal grounds. An open WiFi hot spot may be the source of such downloading without the subscriber even knowing it.
  5. While an ISP will not be able to see the content using a VPN, all the ISP will be looking for is a high traffic volume. If their traffic thresholds are exceeded, customers will be assumed guilty of illegal downloading. There is no way to keep the ISP from discovering which subscribers have a high traffic volume.

    Its no wonder the ISPs agreed to this since most of them want caps on traffic volume; this gives the ISPs an "excuse" to apply those caps.
  6. RzmmDX

    RzmmDX TS Enthusiast Posts: 180   +25

    So, would i have to pay my isps more for them to develop this new system which in no way benefits me?
  7. IvanAwfulitch

    IvanAwfulitch TS Enthusiast Posts: 239   +11

    I'm not ignorant enough to suggest that my habits aren't being viewed already, but giving ISPs license to implement a punishment system as well as lawful ability to invade my privacy so openly is ridiculous.

    What if you're an artist who chooses to upload a torrent file of your own music to promote sales? There are innumerable artists who have chosen to do just that. How does this help them? Clearly it's another case of more for the haves and less for the have-nots. It's not even about piracy, and it never was.

    Net neutrality is in tatters. The tyranny of the rich is flaunted again, and the indifference of the masses allows it to flourish, as always. The public will protest, but their lack of action will welcome this new legislation with open arms.

    Artix, it isn't about if you think their punishment system is fair or not. It's about letting them implement it in the first place. And the RIAA shouldn't be allowed to do so. It doesn't matter if you think you can circumvent it. You give them power by allowing the law to pass, and you're giving up more and more of your personal liberties in the process.
  8. JayT1803

    JayT1803 TS Rookie

    Yea, and how are they going to find out if a person is illegally file sharing?? By simply discriminating against people who use a lot of bandwidth?
  9. Assuming this 'scheme' actually works out for them, you would still get away with file sharing through public wifi, i.e. at McDonalds or a coffee shop, would you not?
  10. Xclusiveitalian

    Xclusiveitalian TS Guru Posts: 679   +46

    "program ISPs will be required to monitor their users' online activities"

    Serious invasion of privacy.
  11. Time to get into the VPN business.
     
  12. soldier1969

    soldier1969 TS Booster Posts: 244   +43

    Vpn service and using peerblock so go ahead monitor my downloading and good luck, been at it for years. Have to me smarter than the man is all.
  13. good thing i installed backtrack a few days ago, now to crack my neighbor's wifi to get those damn rednecks busted. maybe that'll stop em from making tracks in my lawn :/
  14. I guess they want me to downgrade my plan from the expensive 250GB package to the simple 25GB package. Oh well, their loss.
  15. Tygerstrike

    Tygerstrike TS Enthusiast Posts: 827   +93

    OMG you ppl act as if you have any rights on the internet. You have the same expectation of privacy on the internet as you have on a cellphone. NONE! You have to go through an ISP or in the case of a cellphone a provider. They have been snooping your info for years. The only right you have is to annonimity to the general web browsing public. You had to register your name and address as well as any information they require with a ISP.
    Think on this......Eventually all that lovely information you have registerd with the ISp will come back on you. Its called being BlackBalled. SO they determine you are a offender to their new policy. They then start blocking you from having your own internet provider. Eventually some of the smarter sheep will try and get a family member or freind to setup the web for them. And in the usual fashion, they will ruin that family members or freinds ability to get internet.
  16. Gars

    Gars TS Enthusiast Posts: 228

    i dont understand for what is the fight
    we all need:
    better speed
    better content

    if im wrong - sorry
  17. H3llion

    H3llion TechSpot Paladin Posts: 968   +99

    That is in terms of the strikes / warnings.
  18. ikesmasher

    ikesmasher TS Evangelist Posts: 1,913   +362

    someone better damn take this to court.
    I mean, seriously. First they are trying to take away religious freedom (requiring catholics to serve contraceptives to employees) and this is the next in numerous attempts to invade privacy. So many basic american rights being violated.
  19. Blah, VPN and Peerblock are the way I do it. They can't monitor for bandwidth usage because that would discriminate against my legit services that I also use, Like, Hulu, Itunes, Netflix, YouTube, Etc... I use much more bandwidth from those services than I do on my pirating. Besides, Torrents, Usenet, IRC, etc... aren't only used for illegal sharing, there are legit purposes, So you can't really even monitor for protocol, ISP would need to monitor for traffic itself, Otherwise I imagine they would be putting themselves in a liability situation for discrimination (Like that ever stopped them).
  20. PinothyJ

    PinothyJ TS Enthusiast Posts: 429   +15

    Man, ISPs in your country are DICKS.

    I feel for you…
  21. well , glad they send thew names of the isps, so time to change to another one !
  22. Zeromus

    Zeromus TS Enthusiast Posts: 231   +7

    Welp better pirate as much you can.
  23. Per Hansson

    Per Hansson TS Server Guru Posts: 1,930   +123 Staff Member

    Well, torrent traffic are used for allot of legitimate purposes, like for example in World Of Warcraft to deliver the patches.
    So if ISP's really want to do this it comes down to watching exactly what traffic flows, for each customer.
    The cost of doing that must be tremendous.
    It's one thing to switch a few packets of data with routers and then complain when X ammount of data have been transferred (We don't have bandwidth caps here but that's what I refer to)

    But to actually analyze every single packet, for every single customer.
    And then compare that to a list of known illegal distribution schemes, my god just getting my head around the complexities of doing this makes my head hurt!
    And exactly what do the ISP's get in return?
  24. captaincranky

    captaincranky TechSpot Addict Posts: 10,680   +880

    Just a quick count, but with my blazing fast 1 meg DSL, I'd have to be downloading 24/7 to hit maybe 125 GB a month. With normal usage, would I even be a blip on the radar....? :confused:

    It seems like you guys with the high bandwidth will beat me, hands down, in the race to get into trouble....:rolleyes:
  25. I wish I had the courage to take to the streets and protest against this corrupt regime.


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.