TechSpot

Upgrade PC or buy a PS3?

By jarulezz
Dec 26, 2011
Post New Reply
  1. Hello everyone!

    Not sure whether this is the right section to post the thread and also I'm sorry the long post btw.

    I just got some cash for Xmas and I'm wondering whether to upgrade my rig or just buy a ps3. I mainly game and will game on my PC, I live in the UK and right now I have £370 saved up, but Im willing to wait a bit more.

    Right now my PC is:

    CPU: Intel Dual Core E2200 @ 2.75Ghz (overclocked)
    Mobo: ASUS P5Q SE/R
    Ram: 2 x Kingston 2GB DDR 2
    Video: ATI Radeon EAH4850 512MB
    HDD: 2 x 80 GB, 1 SATA, 1 IDE
    Sound: Realtek/Logitech X-540
    OS: Windows XP SP3 32-bit

    And I would like to upgrade to:

    CPU: Intel i5 2500k @ 3.3Ghz (i might overclock to 4Ghz)
    Mobo: ASUS P8P67
    Ram: GSkill Ripjaws x or GSkill Sniper (both kits DDR3, 2x4Gb (8Gb), 1600Mhz)
    Video: (same as above)
    HDD: (same as above) but might get a WD Caviar Blue 500GB or Seagate Barracuda 500GB
    Sound: (same as above)
    OS: I have to get Windows 7 64-bit for the RAM to fully work

    And I also would like to get a case for good airflow and I was thinking about this one:
    Case: Corsair 600t
    but I am open to suggestions (if it has fans, preferably blue or white)

    And a good CPU cooler for overclocking:
    Cooler: Noctua NH-D14

    Now, the upgrade would cost me (prices from Amazon):
    No case: around £335
    With case: around £470
    With Noctua: around £535

    So, looking at my budget and the prices for the compulsory components (£335) i could buy that. But that would mean high temperatures for my CPU, because I've got crappy airflow in this case (1 case fan in, 1 case fan out)

    Now, a PS3 Slim 320GB budle with 3 games (FIFA12, BF3, Uncharted 3) is for £250.
    or a PS3 Slim 160GB with either FIFA12 or BF3 is for £190.

    Im not interested in an Xbox because of Xbox live Gold, I want to play online without additional payments.

    Now, i cant decide what to get - I always gamed on a PC, but I realised that since I started building my own rigs, I spent over a £1000, where I could have got a console and could game on it till now. But I heard that PS4 will come out in late 2012 - but I dont want to wait another year.
    But then again, games for PC are cheaper than for PS3.

    I've played a bit on a PS3, but Im not as good on the consoles as I am with the mouse and keyboard, but I could buy the EagleEye accessory (because I would have spare cash) and use the both instead of a controller.

    I would like some advice from you guys or suggestions to maybe get a cheaper rig, but I think thats like the cheapest and best I could find. I have a spare 32" LCD TV laying around in the house.What would you go for?
     
  2. raybay

    raybay TS Evangelist Posts: 10,716   +6

    The Corsair 600T is a fine case... just built a new computer using one... Get a Corsair Mosular power supply to go with it... The White one is very striking.
     
  3. SKYSTAR

    SKYSTAR TS Enthusiast Posts: 250

    if you want to play hardcore pc games like BF3 , then you need to upgrade your Graphics card too, so if you don't want to pay a lot of money , then PS3 will be a better choice for you.
     
  4. hellokitty[hk]

    hellokitty[hk] Hello, nice to meet you! Posts: 4,376   +127

    A graphics card upgrade is definitely required; I'd think just a CPU upgrade won't help much.

    Why choose a high-end Noctua cooler for a budget build? The 2500k doesn't even need serious cooling for a 3.8ghz+ overclock. On top of that you can always use the stock cooler (if it comes with one) until you get the money to upgrade. You'll still be able overclock a bit with the stock cooler.

    For sure you should hold off on the hard drive purchase.

    This doesn't seem like an extremely hot build so I think you could reuse your case if you wanted.

    You should look into student discounts (if possible obviously) for Windows 7, that'll cost $30 USD.

    You can also consider an AMD based computer, which would be fairly reasonable at this price range.
     
  5. jarulezz

    jarulezz TS Member Topic Starter Posts: 62

    I was looking at AMD setups, mobos are around £80 and a 6-core FX6100 was £100.
    But i read that 6-core only uses 3 core, but has 6 threads - whereas the i5 2500k uses 4 cores.

    what if i bought another hd4850 and crossfired them? will that be enough

    but, if i have to upgrade me GPU as well, then I think Im just going to buy a ps3. I might just buy a better LGA775 cpu to play older games.

    Thanks for the info guys!
     
  6. slh28

    slh28 TechSpot Paladin Posts: 1,925   +170

    I think the Corsair 600T and the Noctua cooler are excessive for your budget, and probably the 2500K is as well. A £60 case and a £20 cooler should be fine for your needs, you're not going into hardcore overclocking territory.

    Another 4850 in CF will give you decent performance in new games, and you can pick one up on ebay for under £40 nowadays. Or alternatively you can sell your 4850 and buy a mid range card (GTX 460, Radeon 6850). So I'm pretty sure you can get decent performance in modern games for your budget.

    It's up to you if you want to buy a console or upgrade your rig, just be aware that PS3 graphics are about the same as low quality on the PC.
     
  7. hellokitty[hk]

    hellokitty[hk] Hello, nice to meet you! Posts: 4,376   +127

    I don't think you have the PCI slots to CF.
     
  8. jarulezz

    jarulezz TS Member Topic Starter Posts: 62

    the p8p67 does have 2 PCI-Express x16 and is CF ready

    but i decided that I dont want to spend all my money and will go for ps3
    pretty sad as i've always favoured pc gaming, but its just so expensive to upgrade :(
     
  9. herpaderp

    herpaderp TS Enthusiast Posts: 159

    This isn't really a question where you should ask others for input. Either you're a PC gamer and you settle for scrounging up cash to upgrade when you can, or you forgo that all together and buy a console and a nice new TV.

    Now if you plan on sticking with PC gaming, you can actually completely re-haul your existing system within your limited budget. An Asus P8P67 will set you back ~£108, an i5 2500k ~£165, 2x4GB DDR3 ~£36, and the Corsair 600T about £128 (all these prices on Scan after VAT).

    This adds up to £417 and is just a bit above your currently set budget.
     
  10. JC713

    JC713 TS Evangelist Posts: 7,035   +914

    you need a good GPU, maybe cut back the ram to 4/6gb and get a new gpu

    this is a good value card for gaming: nVidia 550ti
     
  11. maestro69

    maestro69 TS Rookie

    sell this and buy ps3
     
     
  12. DevilDevansh

    DevilDevansh TS Member Posts: 53

    upgrade your pc

    Trust me don't go for ps3. Only if you could get a better graphics card, pc is better:)
     
  13. DevilDevansh

    DevilDevansh TS Member Posts: 53

    pc is better as its easier to mod em . I just modded my GTA 3 and after so many years, here I am playing it all over again.
     


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...


Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.