Windows 10's Feature Experience Pack hints at a more modular future for the OS

Humza

Posts: 1,026   +171
Staff member
What just happened? Microsoft has added a new item under Settings->About (Windows Specifications) called Windows Feature Experience Pack for users on Windows 10 and Server who've updated their PCs to version 2004 (May 2020 update). Apart from the feature being a collection of 'critical' shell components with a 44.15 MB install size, Microsoft has not given detailed info on what the pack might be or what it does, leading some to believe it could be in preparation for a more modular future for Windows 10, allowing the company to push feature updates for core apps outside of regular OS updates.

Windows 10's May 2020 update brings several new features and changes to the OS, not all of which will be immediately visible or seem useful to users. One of these is the Windows Feature Experience Pack that automatically installs with this update as part of Microsoft's Available Features on Demand.

The feature list includes several well-known Windows programs and components like Notepad, Wordpad, Paint, PowerShell ISE, DirectX Configuration Database, OpenSSH client, and Quick Assistant among others, which Microsoft bundles in the Windows 10 Image file (ISO).

Some of these items, including the new Feature Experience Pack, are now preinstalled in Windows 10 2004 ISO, and users on this version will notice its presence under their PC Settings. Although its purpose isn't immediately clear, Microsoft is said to have been working on this pack for the past few months, which it says "includes features critical to Windows functionality" and therefore advises against its removal.

Unlike the Windows Experience Pack for previous OS versions (XP, Vista, and 7) that affected Live Messenger and the system theme, ZDNet's Mary Jo Foley says that this new pack could be a way for Microsoft to bundle together features that will be updated faster than the Windows 10 OS itself.

The current list of programs in the Feature Experience Pack is fairly small and includes updated versions of the Snipping tool, text input panel, and shell-suggestion UI. With this modular approach, Microsoft would now be able to bypass Windows Update and release newer versions of these components, and those added later, through the Microsoft Store.

The effort also appears to be in-line with the company's revised Windows 10X plans, allowing it to test shell components by bundling them together in future Insider builds and optimizing the OS' UI/UX for upcoming devices.

Apart from the Windows Feature Experience Pack and several other changes in version 2004, the update also packs in its usual share of bugs as well. According to Windows Latest, the May 2020 update has caused issues with Microsoft's Optimize Drives tool.

Although the utility defrags or trims storage media as it should, the program is unable to report the correct status for when the disks were last optimized. While it's not a problem for users running third-party programs for maintaining drives, it's potentially concerning for those solely relying on Microsoft's tool.

The company was made aware of this problem in a previous Insider build, and a fix was included in January's Preview Build 19551. The issue, however, seemingly slipped through the public build and is now expected to be patched in a future cumulative update.

Permalink to story.

 
Its just some small errors that can be patched. now defrag just go fast trough ssd drives and if that's a error or just the speed of a NVME SSD disk inside you're laptop desktop arm device. in windows ME it was just downloading a defrag update. then defrag program was normal again. does this repeat in win 10 too ?
 
Hmmmm ..... based upon past experience you can put your money on the fact that they are up to no good. If it was such a benefit to the users they would be advertising the heck out of it.
Indeed. And if anyone really needs "new" features regularly added to Notepad, just download Notepad++ (which has had what MS are "inventing" since 2003...)

"While it's not a problem for users running third-party programs..."
From Notepad to Notepad++, Paint to Paint.NET, Sound Recorder to Audacity, Windows Media Player to VLC / MPC-BE, "zip folders" to 7zip, etc, replacing Windows defaults with 3rd party programs is virtually an immediate post-install necessity across the board...
 
Indeed. And if anyone really needs "new" features regularly added to Notepad, just download Notepad++ (which has had what MS are "inventing" since 2003...)


From Notepad to Notepad++, Paint to Paint.NET, Sound Recorder to Audacity, Windows Media Player to VLC / MPC-BE, "zip folders" to 7zip, etc, replacing Windows defaults with 3rd party programs is virtually an immediate post-install necessity across the board...

The main point has been that the basic Microsoft tools have been available on every Windows PC. You can guarantee that they are there, even on locked-down systems that you can install anything on.

So this news is... mixed. I doubt they are going to remove these programs from the base install, but you won't be able to guarantee that they are the latest versions. With such basic tools though, that shouldn't be too much of a problem.

And as for them being inferior? Well, yes, but I find their designs to be completely minimal and better looking than the alternatives you posted. And Paint 3D; that's a legitimately good program.
 
Back