Editors Liked

  • Choices made earlier in the series matter in big ways
  • Asher and Rodrik's paths
  • Some thought-provoking decisions
  • A lot of shocking moments, acted wonderfully by the cast

Editors Didn't Like

  • Magical elements feel out of place
  • Too little resolution
  • The North Grove is a letdown
  • No real ending to speak of, meaning that the season doesn't feel like a complete tale