Editors Liked

  • Claire and Moira's campaign feels drastically different from Barry and Natalia's
  • More old-school Resi feel
  • Sloshing through a perilous sewer freshens up the challenge of exploration

Editors Didn't Like

  • Barry's chapter drags
  • No online play
  • You may have to backtrack to a previous episode to trigger the best ending
  • Co-op partners are relegated to puzzle solution tools, not equal partners