Editors Liked

  • Incredible scope
  • Loads of challenging quests
  • Fun new enemies and allies
  • Choices that matter are scattered throughout
  • Beautiful living world
  • Warmly familiar to fans of the Gothic series
  • Stable
  • Choices result in tangible consequences
  • Well acted characters
  • A lot of well constructed
  • Interconnected quests

Editors Didn't Like

  • Very challenging combat can be too much for some
  • Last half of the game becomes too linear and mostly limited to main quests
  • Final battle is one of the most disappointing in years Source
  • The combat is awkward and unsatisfying
  • Various technical glitches
  • Takes a long time to get interesting