Editors Liked

  • Gameplay stays true to the series, Looks great, The Monkey Island humors intact
  • Feels like returning to an old friend
  • A great revival of the classic games; quirky humor; original voice actors make it feel like home
  • Challenging but logical puzzles, Brilliantine humor, Fantastic script, Beautiful art, It’s Monkey Island, as good as Monkey Island has ever been

Editors Didn't Like

  • Just three hours of gameplay, No replay value
  • Having to wait for the next instalment
  • Some annoying maze sequences; the art styles a little bit jarring compared with whats come before
  • An annoying maze section, A whole month until the next one, Needlessly altered control scheme