Editors Liked

  • Terrific writing
  • Memorable scenes
  • Great characters
  • Scary villain
  • Moral dilemmas continue to hold center stage
  • Not afraid to put Clementine in situations applicable of an apocalypse
  • If Telltale can maintain this standard for the rest of the season, it could yet top The Walking Dead's first run in terms of quality - if not novelty
  • Unrelentingly brutal, underlining how much of their humanity the survivors have to sacrifice to stay alive
  • Gruesome final scene represents the series' bleak choices at their most intense

Editors Didn't Like

  • Some two-dimensional supporting players