Editors Liked

  • Looks gorgeous for the most part, has a great (if a tad clichéd) atmosphere, enjoyable naval combat (at least to begin with)
  • Beautiful ships; Fun naval combat; Excellent voice-overs and music

Editors Didn't Like

  • Extremely linear and restricting and as such gets dull and repetitive far too quickly, no incentive to play through multiple times
  • Poor land combat; Linear structure; Bad enemy AI; Stealth missions