TechSpot

Weekend tech reading: Why the PC still matters

By Matthew
Jul 15, 2012
Post New Reply
  1. Many, including Apple's Tim Cook and Steve Jobs before him, believe that we're entering a "Post-PC era" where smartphones, tablets and cloud-powered thin clients like Google's Chromebooks will eliminate traditional computers. Sales numbers seem to...

    Read more
     
  2. Jay Pfoutz

    Jay Pfoutz Malware Helper Posts: 4,286   +49

    Oh no...here we go again with the post-PC era. There goes all our paychecks. :p
     
  3. Ranger12

    Ranger12 TS Guru Posts: 637   +117

    I think desktops will be around for the foreseeable future just because the newest and fastest hardware never fits in laptops, tablets, or smartphones. My desktop today is the same size as my desktop I built ten years ago. The latest and greatest hardware is introduced for desktops because desktops are uniquely capable of the cooling and power needs of new hardware.
     
    ReederOnTheRun likes this.
  4. treetops

    treetops TS Evangelist Posts: 1,690   +60

  5. Julio Franco

    Julio Franco TechSpot Editor Posts: 6,577   +344

    I believe it's a matter of form factor, not just performance alone. I can get some work done using mobile devices (smartphone, tablet, etc.), but on my desktop I'm more comfortable for longer hours and I'm way more productive.
     
  6. ikesmasher

    ikesmasher TS Evangelist Posts: 1,951   +388

    I agree with above.
     
  7. Benny26

    Benny26 TechSpot Paladin Posts: 1,576   +47

    I also agree with Julio here.

    A few weeks back I moved house and considered dropping my broadband in the new house due to being able to do pretty much everything on my phone in regards to the Internet. Only took me a week or so to realize it was getting tedious having to focus for long periods on the phone. Eventually I got my Internet back and noticed there's nothing more comfortable than the desktop.
     
  8. Desktop for most everything..Like said above, phone or tablet not that good for long periods of time.Plus the older you get the bigger the screen you need to be read websites easier..IMO.:)
     
  9. Adhmuz

    Adhmuz TechSpot Paladin Posts: 935   +106

    You know, god forbid you sit down at a desk and use a computer, when it comes to working and being productive being on the go is one of the most distracting things. When you are at a desk chances are theres a reason for it, and you have something to do. This can all still be done from a laptop connected to a kvm, but its just not the same even with the performance boost of resent years. Expandability (Upgraded-ability), connectivity and performance all specialties of the desktop computer, something no other device can do. Also glad to hear the 3D fad has already moved on, what a useless concept (For the entertainment industry exclusively)
     
  10. ikesmasher

    ikesmasher TS Evangelist Posts: 1,951   +388

    I'm actually surprised that convertible tablet notebooks/netbooks didn't hit a bigger market- they are really cool. Maybe with Windows 8 we will see that more.
     
  11. TomSEA

    TomSEA TechSpot Chancellor Posts: 2,358   +403

    I commented from day one that the whole 3D fad was just that. Amazing how manufacturer's decided (apparently without any customer research), that since "Avatar" was a big hit, that meant everyone wanted 3D and tried to cram it down our throat in every way, shape and form.

    I personally don't know of a single person who has made a purchase in the last 3-4 years based on 3D capabilities. I suspect in 2 years it will be completely gone only to resurface as "the next big thing" 30 years down the road.
     
     
  12. Sounds like yet another group of CEOs high on their own success. I can see smartphones becoming more important than PCs but I cannot envisage the end of the PC. There is simply no substitute for a big screen and the greater capabilities we get as the hardware gets larger.
     
  13. ET3D

    ET3D TechSpot Paladin Posts: 984   +31

    A lot of businesses have moved to laptops. Both me and my wife are software developers and we work on laptops. They are hooked to decent keyboards, mice and often monitors. They're more costly and less powerful than desktops, but they have advantages, such as being mobile (you can just take your work as is home or abroad or to present it at a meeting) and surviving power outages (without need for bulky UPS's which last for only a few minutes).

    I think that desktops will continue to be around, but they'll continue to be marginalised.

    As for 3D, the problem is that it's not convenient. Even if you don't need to wear special glasses, you have to adjust the depth of the game, you have to keep your head just so. In the end the result is just not worth the hassle. For some people the hassle is great. I can't go to movies with my wife because most of them are 3D and she finds the glasses extremely uncomfortable and doesn't see the 3D well.
     
  14. MilwaukeeMike

    MilwaukeeMike TS Evangelist Posts: 2,133   +731

    Form factor is unrelated. Like ET3D above me, I work for a company that has us all on laptops with docking stations so we can bring them home and to meetings. It's not a stretch to say a phone will be able to do this, but in many cases we're already past the desktop PC.
    For my home however... I can't imagine not having a desktop. Even if performance gets there someday, I still like building my PC.
     
  15. MarkHughes

    MarkHughes TS Member Posts: 42

    I am a software developer and at my company we all use laptops with docking stations. I also use a laptop at home for my personal use, I don't have a desktop anymore. But I might get one again in the future as they do have merit as people above have rightly said.
     
  16. Johnny Pappis

    Johnny Pappis TS Rookie

    Exactly people dont understand that technology needs to start out in a certain form factor and it takes alot of R&D to shrink it down to the size of say a tablet or smart phone but when it first comes out towers are where its at, Desktops are becoming the sports car of Computing it caters to a smaller and smaller part of the market but thats where the power is for enthusiasts!
     
  17. Marnomancer

    Marnomancer TS Booster Posts: 808   +51

    Haha, +1.
    I said the same thing about that auto-problem-handler thingy. Tech-support's future is in doubt. :confused:

    Really, the PC is here to stay for a long time - in evolving forms, but yes, always there.
     
    DragonMasterJay likes this.
  18. People who claim that the PC era is nearing its end, obviously have never been very productive with computers to begin with and that is a FACT. I don't seem myself rendering HD movies, 3D models, watching HD movies, editing large image in Photoshop or doing work in Excel on a phone, tablet or even a laptop. It's not just about computer power but also about high end software, a rock solid keyboard, one or more 24-27" monitors, extra drives, DVD/BLu-Ray burners, high end audio, etc plus being able to build your own machine and maintain it without have to rely on service centers, repair costs, delays, etc or being able to upgrade every partm, without being forced to buy a complete machine. Even with a laptop you're very limited. My daughter has a 3 year old laptop and her touchpad is failing. Good luck repairing that yourself. Good luck upgrading its processor or adding a better graphics card. No, you guys can go ahead with your silly tablets and laptops as your main computer, I need a real machine!
     
  19. seem= see
     
  20. Lionvibez

    Lionvibez TS Enthusiast Posts: 605   +89

    Couldn't have said it any better my friend.

    Leave the tablets for the isheep.

    Real men use desktop computers lol!
     
  21. davimous

    davimous TS Rookie Posts: 55   +9

    Some people drive smart cars and some people drive sports cars.
     
  22. Some people drive smart sports cars, some drive non-smart, non-sports cars.
    Furthermore, some drive smart but non-sports cars, yet more non-smart sports cars,
    and some just don't drive at all.
    Some people just have a wine gum lodged in their anus like David Orcus.
     
  23. nismo91

    nismo91 TS Guru Posts: 1,004   +11

    I used to rely on laptop for my primary machine, until last year I realized it's too darn expensive for me to get a laptop which is as powerful as my budget rig. sure I have to sync files manually between my desktop and laptop, but it's much cheaper, faster and easily upgrade / downgradeable. there's one time I realized I'm only running on 1360x768 32" LCD and most of my games therefore doesn't even require a GTX560Ti. downgrade back to 8800GT with older PSU and sell both for a Logitech G27. wouldn't be possible if it isn't a desktop PC.

    so is PC still matters? the hell it is. I'd prefer to do long-hours work on my desktop PC on fairly large LCD using full sized ergonomics keyboard and mouse. I used laptop if im on the go but it wont last me long before im gone tired or RSI occured.
     


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.