Epic avoiding the Play Store prompted Google to create a 'Fortnite task force'

midian182

Posts: 7,761   +78
Staff member
In context: With so much news coverage of Epic Games’ battle with Apple, it’s easy to forget that Google is also involved in the legal spat. The search giant was so concerned about Fortnite initially skipping its app store in favor of Samsung’s Galaxy Store and Epic's website that it set up a task force to deal with the issue.

Bloomberg reports that details of Google’s task force were revealed in a legal filing, part of Google countersuing Epic over claims that the latter pushed an “unapproved” version of Fortnite on Android phones that placed users at risk.

Epic’s response includes details of the task force. According to internal documents, it was set up in 2018 and met daily to deal with Fortnite bypassing Google’s store. It’s claimed that part of the group’s work included focusing on a potential security issue for anyone sideloading Fortnite.

Google usually gives app makers 90 days to address any flaws before publicly disclosing them, but it waited just nine days before revealing this issue to “friendlies” in the media. According to the filing, Google did this to “deter developers from launching outside of Google Play and maintain Google’s monopoly over Android app distribution.”

While Google’s app security page explains it can disclose vulnerabilities sooner or later than 90 days in “extreme circumstances,” the filing states that even Google’s own software engineers felt the security warnings about Fortnite were excessive. The head of Android security wrote in an email that the message to users “really does seem inappropriately dire,” Epic said.

Google has defended its actions, of course. It says that the vulnerabilities that were present in Fortnite on Android could have compromised consumers’ data. “Safety and security are our top priorities, so of course we took steps to warn our users about this security flaw, in accordance with our App Security policy. We’ll continue to fight Epic’s claims in court,” said spokesperson Peter Schottenfels.

Fortnite eventually came to the Google Play Store in April 2020, 18 months after it first became available on Android. Epic pulled no punches in its explanation as to why it relented: “Google puts software downloadable outside of Google Play at a disadvantage, through technical and business measures such as scary, repetitive security pop-ups for downloaded and updated software, restrictive manufacturer and carrier agreements and dealings, Google public relations characterizing third party software sources as malware, and new efforts such as Google Play Protect to outright block software obtained outside the Google Play Store,” the company said in a statement. “Because of this, we’ve launched Fortnite for Android on the Google Play Store.”

Permalink to story.

 

Dimitriid

Posts: 2,074   +3,977
I have no doubts that Google has just as much interest in that 30% cut as Apple, but if their tactics are to have daily meeting and trying to find "dirt" via somewhat legitimate security issues, that seems to be pretty mild compared to "Ban them from our storefront and remove their software" response.

It honestly reads like the top bros or someone high up in Google wanted something done and the team did something so stereotypical for office employees I could totally see Dwight Schrute in charge of this task force with Jim and Pam mocking his security solutions the entire episode.
 

Theinsanegamer

Posts: 3,317   +5,502
I have no doubts that Google has just as much interest in that 30% cut as Apple, but if their tactics are to have daily meeting and trying to find "dirt" via somewhat legitimate security issues, that seems to be pretty mild compared to "Ban them from our storefront and remove their software" response.

It honestly reads like the top bros or someone high up in Google wanted something done and the team did something so stereotypical for office employees I could totally see Dwight Schrute in charge of this task force with Jim and Pam mocking his security solutions the entire episode.
I'm not even sure what they would plan here. Android, unlike iOS, is an open (ish) platform. Epic could (and has) simply offer the game for download outside of the play store. Unlike apple, on google's system you have options. They cant just force their hand like apple did.
 

yRaz

Posts: 4,330   +4,965
So, what was the vulnerability that was so dire? They didn't say what it was only what it could do. So my question is, does it actually exist?
 

Irata

Posts: 2,033   +3,452
I'm not even sure what they would plan here. Android, unlike iOS, is an open (ish) platform. Epic could (and has) simply offer the game for download outside of the play store. Unlike apple, on google's system you have options. They cant just force their hand like apple did.
That‘s actually how I installed it on my kid‘s Android phone when he first got one.
 

Cubi Dorf

Posts: 372   +244
Of course they are going to play the security card. It work for Apple. Because everyone know only secure app can come from Apple and Google. Any app distributed by bad company such as Epic is insecure if it does not come from our app store!
 

kiwigraeme

Posts: 977   +711
You would of thought google would of covered their derriere better with the shortening off the 90 days . With a simple this is unusual as is very popular - especially with kids - so a much larger attack vector .
Anyway no contract is formed - as no third party is offering anything - that does mean you don't have legal rights to action - only it's much harder - eg when you promise someone something for no exchange of value and that person puts themself out for other costs - you may be liable .
English case law - a person buys other decor based on your promise to give them a certain coloured set of curtains - they were found liable to supply curtains