TSMC Arizona lawsuit alleges anti-American discrimination, racist remarks, buttock slapping, and Temu safety harnesses

midian182

Posts: 10,821   +142
Staff member
WTF?! A class action lawsuit against TSMC over allegations that the company discriminates against American workers while favoring those from Taiwan has been refiled to include over 30 plaintiffs. The suit claims that an anti-American bias exists at the semiconductor giant, and that non-Asian employees were called "stupid" or "lazy." One plaintiff said he heard Taiwanese employees say that "Black people are lazy and smell."

More than a dozen current and former TSMC Arizona employees filed the class-action lawsuit in 2024. It was refiled in June with 15 new plaintiffs.

The world's largest chipmaker is accused of bullying US workers, restricting their advancement, forcing them out of the company, and being biased toward hiring Taiwanese and Chinese nationals.

One of the plaintiffs, former TSMC senior technician Phillip Sterbinsky, said he was routinely yelled at by managers and called "stupid and lazy." He also heard racist remarks from Taiwanese workers. Sterbinsky was the only non-Asian remaining in his department when he left in 2024.

One plaintiff said that during a meeting, a Taiwanese frontline manager said, "I'm so embarrassed; Americans are lazy, they don't work hard enough, they don't know enough, and they don't know commitment."

Marcus Hernandez, another plaintiff, says he witnessed multiple safety violations at the Arizona plant, including managers pressuring him to turn on the chemical supply to the fab machines without wearing correct safety gear. The suit also claims that TSMC attempted to buy safety harnesses from Temu.

Part of the suit claims that TSMC favors hiring Chinese or Taiwanese workers at the Arizona site. Some advertised positions asked for proficiency in Mandarin, even though speaking the language wasn't a requirement for the jobs. It's also alleged that the higher-ranking Taiwanese workers regularly speak "Chenglish" so non-East Asian employees don't understand them, thereby preventing US staff from advancing at TSMC.

Invitations to job fairs were also in Chinese, and key meetings were held in Chinese or Mandarin in order to exclude non-East Asians, according to the suit.

Another complaint is that TSMC's HR team in Taiwan sends the US branch of the company resumes of vetted candidates who can work in the US. The US team then hires "these Asian/Taiwanese candidates without question, even if no open roles have been posted in the US." It's also claimed TSMC is hiring Taiwanese employees on visas as a way to reduce the number of union positions for US workers.

When asked why Taiwanese nationals had replaced Americans who had left TSMC, senior HR director Ted Chiang allegedly said it was because TSMC "is an Asian company."

There are also claims that one male US worker was repeatedly patted on the buttocks by older Taiwanese male engineers. The same person said he arrived at work in 2024 to "find a rubber chicken hanging from the ceiling over the desk of his Black colleague."

It was reported in June last year that US staff at TSMC Arizona were complaining about twelve-hour days, common weekend shifts, and a "brutal" work-life balance. There were also complaints about poor training, stress, heavy workloads, and a militaristic atmosphere. Mark Liu, TSMC's chairman at the time, said that the company does not ask US employees to conform to the same work culture standards as those observed in Taiwan, suggesting that American employees have it easier than those in the Asian nation.

Permalink to story:

 
It's true that the Taiwanese work much harder and are more productive, but the West as a whole has much worse productivity. No wonder Intel has fallen behind.

While I’m not into the flakey style of management and productivity that is so common these days, some of the reported things in the article go to subpar ethical standards. Merit-based hiring and talent doesn’t require 12-hour shifts. That may be the standard in Asia, but not here. Asia may lead in productivity, but they also lead in corporate suicides…
 
It's true that the Taiwanese work much harder and are more productive, but the West as a whole has much worse productivity. No wonder Intel has fallen behind.
True but Intel is a Western company with Western workers. This is an eastern company with eastern work ethics at its core with eastern workers in the hierarchy structure via admin. So more like a hybrid vs Intel. There are many eastern companies that had this hybrid work structure and yet had success in the west like Toyota and many others. If anything the glass is half full thier management is lazy on finding the right staff and training them correctly on meeting the company's expectations imo! The west has a spectrum of workers from ultra lazy to ultra productive which is just a summation of the rest of the world. I believe Intel's problem stems from upper management. When workforce lags behind management usually picks up the slack if the work is further left behind and deadlines are not met because management did not pick up the slack and discipline accordingly the company will start to fail. TSMC's upper management is probably picking up a lot of the work left behind hence the resentment maybe even due to work exhaustion. I wonder if their HR was even fit to handle such a workforce.
 
Times are changing. I work at a bank that has let go half of its IT workforce, and now states the expected workday to be 16 hours for the remaining staff. They know that cannot be legally enforced, but they have mentioned performance reviews would take into account who is putting in more hours, with future layoffs targeting those that are not meeting expectations. They could care less about a work-life balance as we are required to have MS Teams on our mobile devices so we can be on call 24/7. I guess the upside is there is no discrimination in play as we’re all being treated in the same poor manner.
 
Should China decide that Taiwan is going to be occupied. TSMC will need the US facilities. So, how about learning how to motivate Americans and not denigrate them. In time, the most committed workers will become apparent. Don't be racist d1cks.
 
Times are changing. I work at a bank that has let go half of its IT workforce, and now states the expected workday to be 16 hours for the remaining staff. They know that cannot be legally enforced, but they have mentioned performance reviews would take into account who is putting in more hours, with future layoffs targeting those that are not meeting expectations. They could care less about a work-life balance as we are required to have MS Teams on our mobile devices so we can be on call 24/7. I guess the upside is there is no discrimination in play as we’re all being treated in the same poor manner.
Uh huh. And nobody has filed a complaint with the relevant labor boards because?

Seems like a pretty open and shut case, if they put it in writing. If they didn't, then let them try to enforce it and put it in writing. Should be an easy lawsuit.
True but Intel is a Western company with Western workers. This is an eastern company with eastern work ethics at its core with eastern workers in the hierarchy structure via admin. So more like a hybrid vs Intel. There are many eastern companies that had this hybrid work structure and yet had success in the west like Toyota and many others. If anything the glass is half full thier management is lazy on finding the right staff and training them correctly on meeting the company's expectations imo! The west has a spectrum of workers from ultra lazy to ultra productive which is just a summation of the rest of the world. I believe Intel's problem stems from upper management. When workforce lags behind management usually picks up the slack if the work is further left behind and deadlines are not met because management did not pick up the slack and discipline accordingly the company will start to fail. TSMC's upper management is probably picking up a lot of the work left behind hence the resentment maybe even due to work exhaustion. I wonder if their HR was even fit to handle such a workforce.
It's true that the Taiwanese work much harder and are more productive, but the West as a whole has much worse productivity. No wonder Intel has fallen behind.
Translation: TSMCs work ethic runs into issues in a country with human rights.
 
Uh huh. And nobody has filed a complaint with the relevant labor boards because?

Seems like a pretty open and shut case, if they put it in writing. If they didn't, then let them try to enforce it and put it in writing. Should be an easy lawsuit.

Translation: TSMCs work ethic runs into issues in a country with human rights.
Slap on the wrist fines and implicit bias training for all staff will probably be the end result.
 
Uh huh. And nobody has filed a complaint with the relevant labor boards because?
Well, as an employee of “the bank”, you have to forfeit your right to obtain legal representation, such as a lawyer. All issues have to be brought up through a third party remediation board. They learned their lesson about ten years ago when there was a class action lawsuit with timecards being required for salary employees. On a personal note in case you’re wondering why I continue to deal with the shenanigans, the job pays very well for now, but I have been contemplating on leaving due to the new level of absurdity.
 
Uh huh. And nobody has filed a complaint with the relevant labor boards because?

Seems like a pretty open and shut case, if they put it in writing. If they didn't, then let them try to enforce it and put it in writing. Should be an easy lawsuit.

Translation: TSMCs work ethic runs into issues in a country with human rights.
Ironically the western country with the most lax human (or at least worker) rights.
If they tried setting up shop in say France or Germany (or maybe the Netherlands, nice and close to ASML) they'd truly be shocked by the amount of time people expect to have off work, get paid maternity leave etc - horrendous for companies. Great for people.

Funnily enough they are planning to do both design and manufacturing in Germany - wonder how that'll go.
 
Ironically the western country with the most lax human (or at least worker) rights.
If they tried setting up shop in say France or Germany (or maybe the Netherlands, nice and close to ASML) they'd truly be shocked by the amount of time people expect to have off work, get paid maternity leave etc - horrendous for companies. Great for people.

Funnily enough they are planning to do both design and manufacturing in Germany - wonder how that'll go.
Partially. Blue states are more strict and also have paternity leave. Red states are probably more laxed. Do European labor laws allow paternity leave?
 
Ironically the western country with the most lax human (or at least worker) rights.
If they tried setting up shop in say France or Germany (or maybe the Netherlands, nice and close to ASML) they'd truly be shocked by the amount of time people expect to have off work, get paid maternity leave etc - horrendous for companies. Great for people.

Funnily enough they are planning to do both design and manufacturing in Germany - wonder how that'll go.

This harms people as well, every inefficiency and added cost eventually turns into inflation, reflected in the price of products and services. The same inflation they constantly complain about.
 
Partially. Blue states are more strict and also have paternity leave. Red states are probably more laxed. Do European labor laws allow paternity leave?
Depends on the country, but even the worst cases are far better than the US.
It is 14 weeks (rather than 12) at the minimum for maternity leave, it is paid rather than unpaid.
Paternity leave is 10 days minimum but often much longer and again paid rather than unpaid (In the US it's 0 and $0).

Some examples exceeding it: Spain gives 16 weeks to both parents. Sweden a massive 390 days (at 80% pay).

Finland is an especially cool example of going the extra mile when it comes to maternity btw. Expectant mothers can pick between being sent either €140, or a 'baby box' by the government. The box contains a whole bunch of baby necessities such as clothes, bedding, bathing products etc and the box itself doubles as a crib with the mattress that's included.
 
Depends on the country, but even the worst cases are far better than the US.
It is 14 weeks (rather than 12) at the minimum for maternity leave, it is paid rather than unpaid.
Paternity leave is 10 days minimum but often much longer and again paid rather than unpaid (In the US it's 0 and $0).

Some examples exceeding it: Spain gives 16 weeks to both parents. Sweden a massive 390 days (at 80% pay).

Finland is an especially cool example of going the extra mile when it comes to maternity btw. Expectant mothers can pick between being sent either €140, or a 'baby box' by the government. The box contains a whole bunch of baby necessities such as clothes, bedding, bathing products etc and the box itself doubles as a crib with the mattress that's included.


And for some reason, birth rates in the developed world are plummeting. It’s not just the US and EU, China, Korea, and Japan to name some examples are either highly developed nations or nations with generous family benefits.
 
Back