Editors Liked

  • Wide array of well-done characters
  • Satisfyingly bone-crunching combat
  • Player movement is incredibly smooth
  • Suspenseful and interesting story
  • New Game-offers many benefits
  • Engaging story with fantastic voice acting
  • Big world with tons of quests and puzzles
  • Smooth-flowing combat and traversal
  • A Batcave's worth of fun gadgets
  • Atmospheric, fascinating world rich with details and secrets
  • Makes terrific use of a host of Batman characters
  • Crime-solving sequences
  • Huge amounts of un-lockable content
  • Ability to play as Catwoman puts a fun new spin on game play

Editors Didn't Like

  • Enemy AI seems a bit slow at times
  • Serious DX11 performance issues
  • Can't change settings in game
  • Three layers of DRM is overkill
  • No PhysX on AMD GPUs
  • Boss fights are too easy
  • Borrows voraciously from previous game
  • Some aspects of story and game play stretch suspension of disbelief too far
  • Boss battles too easy
  • Many side missions don’t compare favorably with main game mode
  • Keyboard control scheme isn't the greatest
  • Needs some post-release patches
  • Catwoman "Online Pass" is bound to be a hassle for used game buyers