TechSpot

Nvidia launches GeForce GTX 465, Fermi gets closer to mainstream pricing

By Julio Franco
May 31, 2010
  1. dividebyzero

    dividebyzero trainee n00b Posts: 4,968   +738

    This promises to be one hell of an article.
    As most of my business system upgrades generally centre around graphics I usually follow the ebb and flow of new cards and driver releases...your's sounds like it's going to put the cat amongst the pigeons!
    A brief look around the tech-web regarding the GTX 470 and HD 5850 comparisons*.....

    GTX 470
    Aliens vs Predator (1680, 1920,2560)Xbit, HC, Toms
    Battlefield BC2: (1680, 1920) Xbit, HC, Toms, Anand + 2560@8xMSAA (HC)
    CoD:MW2 : (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit, Hexus, Toms
    Far Cry 2: (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit, TPU, HC, HH
    Metro 2033: (1680) Xbit, HC
    STALKER:CoP : (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit, Anand
    STALKER:SoC : (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    STALKER:CS : (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    Just Cause 2: (1680, 1920) Xbit, HC, Toms
    Resident Evil 5: (1680) Xbit
    Street Fighter IV: (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit
    Mass Effect 2: (1680) Xbit, Anand
    DIRT 2: (1680, 1920)Xbit, Hexus, HC, Toms, Anand, TPU
    HAWX : (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit, TPU, HH, Anand
    Battleforge (DX10 and DX11) (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit, Anand, TPU
    World in Conflict:Sov.Assault (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit
    CoD 4:MW (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    Call of Juarez 2 (1680) TPU
    Company of Heroes (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    Dawn of War 2 (1680) TPU
    ET:QW : (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU, HH
    Far Cry : (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    UT3 : (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    World in Conflict (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    Left 4 Dead 2 : (1680, 1920) HH

    split
    Battlefield:BC2 @1920:Hexus (HD5850), Xbit, HC, Toms (GTX470)
    Crysis Warhead @1680 & 2560: Hexus (HD5850), Xbit, Anand (GTX470)
    Just Cause 2 (2560) : Xbit (HD5850), HC (GTX470)
    Mass Effect 2: (1920) Xbit (GTX470), Anand (HD5850)
    Call of Juarez 2 (1920) identical fps (TPU)

    HD5850
    Battlefield BC2 (2560) Xbit, Anand, HC
    Crysis Warhead (1920) Xbit, Hexus, Anand
    Metro 2033: (1920, 2560) Xbit, HC
    Wolfenstein (1680, 1920, 2560) Xbit, Anand
    Resident Evil 5 : (1920, 2560) Xbit
    Mass Effect 2: (2560) Xbit, Anand
    DIRT 2 (2560) Xbit, Hexus, HC, Toms, Anand, TPU
    Left 4 Dead: (1680, 1920, 2560) Anand
    Call of Juarez 2 (2560) TPU
    Dawn of War 2 (1920, 2560) TPU
    Crysis (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU, Toms, HH
    Prey (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    Quake 4 (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    Riddick: Dark Athena (1680, 1920, 2560) TPU
    Left 4 Dead 2 (2560) HH

    From the wide range of games (and leaving out titles that heavily favour nVidia cards- Batman:AA, Mirror's Edge, Darkest of Days and Dark Void) the honours seem fairly well split-if anything the HD5850 tends to pick up wins at 2560x1600 that include benches of academic interest only as the framerates are too low for gameplay- so I'm keen to see how Techspots benches differ from what I've seen so far.

    * As these are enthusiasts cards I did not look at a resolution below 1600, nor any game setting without antialiasing if it is supported in game or can be forced.
    Reviews referenced used the latest nVidia beta driver and for the most part Catalyst 10.5. (10.3a most dated )

    Reviews cited: TechPowerUp (TPU), Xbit, Anandtech, Hardware Canucks (HC), Tom's Hardware, Hot Hardware (HH), Hexus.
     
  2. Steve

    Steve TechSpot Staff Posts: 1,463   +508 Staff Member

    @dividebyzero – Hmm that is hardly conclusive. Half the games listed as favoring the GeForce GTX 470 reappear in the Radeon HD 5850 list. Looking over our results they are quite similar to those from the Anand review though we tested with a few different games as well. It seems the setting play a significant role in which card comes out on top though that is hardly surprising. For our article we have tested using maximum in-game quality settings with AA/AF enabled. Anyway that is all I am going to say for now, the article should be live tomorrow.
     
  3. Regenweald

    Regenweald TS Rookie Posts: 143

    I have no idea where the nvidia fans get their numbers to justify some of their claims, but "a buddy of mine" is not acceptable :) Fermi has made the gaming community look like *****s, they keep arguing tessellation performance, but the only place you can enjoy that 'superior' tessellation is in a benchmark. When was the last time anyone 'played' a benchmark ? So for more money, more heat and more power draw, you get to sit and watch the Heaven benchmark in a loop ?

    If the next Nvidia architecture is genuinely better than ATI, I'm there, because I'm a *performance* hound. Green lost this round boys, deal with it.
     
  4. dividebyzero

    dividebyzero trainee n00b Posts: 4,968   +738

    Games are listed under the respective cards by resolution. So, for arguments sake, Game "A" might favour the GTX 470 at 1680 and 1920 resolutions, while the same Game "A" might favour the HD 5850 at 2560. Sorry for the confusion.

    I think you would need to add some other games since Anand had the GTX 470 "winning" 22 of the 30 benchmarks (average 6.99% faster framerate overall). Considering Anand decided to forego a lot of best selling game titles (CoD series, WoW:WotLK, GTA4) which favour nVidia arch/coding then it seems a fair comparison.

    @Regenweald
    A few points...
    Without the hardware to make use of tesselation, there is little point releasing games that feature it.
    Metro 2033 and AvP feature moderate amounts of tesselation- both of these new games favour nVidia's architecture by a fair margin. With Battlefield 1943, F1 2010 and Crysis 2 looming.
    If tesselation is such a ho-hum non event why is AMD re-jigging it's architecture for Southern Islands to be more tessalation capable?
     
  5. princeton

    princeton TS Addict Posts: 1,716

    Then you guys might want to rethink how you benchmark. Every review I have seen shows the nvidia cards as better. Heres some quotes from the guru3d benchmark.

    "Even so, when we tally up the results out of all titles tested, the GeForce GTX 480 wins nearly everywhere"

    "there are also scenarios where the GTX 480 completely and utterly kicks the Radeon HD 5870 in the proverbial nuts."

    "The GeForce GTX 470 then -- obviously this card is lined up against ATI's Radeon HD 5850. It can compete with it quite well. Price wise it's definitely the more interesting of the two cards tested today."

    Ill quote that again
    "Price wise it's definitely the more interesting of the two cards tested today."

    "Money versus performance wise I'd say the GTX 470 is the winner of the two really"

    Yup the ati cards are sure cheaper and faster. Reviews on guru3d, hardwarecanucks,bit-tech among others say different.
     
  6. dividebyzero

    dividebyzero trainee n00b Posts: 4,968   +738

    Well, so much for that idea. Looks like Galaxy have got a GTX470x2 on display at Computex. 2 x 8pin PCIe + PCI slot (375w) still seems a litle light on the power delivery side and not much in the way of case venting. More keen on finding out what kind of heatsink they're planning on using!
     
  7. Steve

    Steve TechSpot Staff Posts: 1,463   +508 Staff Member

    @ princeton - you are right the GeForce GTX 480 is superior to the Radeon HD 5870. That was the conclusion in our NDA coverage anyway.
     
  8. I had an ATI 5850 but had too many problems with cursor artifacts, black screens or lines in the screen requiring a hard re-boot that I decided to try the GTX470 instead. The ATI forums were filled with threads of similar problems with no solution. My 470 hasn't had any issues but it does run hot sometimes. I'll occasionaly use alt-tab to switch over to EVGA Precision to check the temps while gaming. You can easily set the fan speed higher to keep temps down.
     
  9. princeton

    princeton TS Addict Posts: 1,716

    you also posted earlier than the hd 5850 was better than the gtx 470. When in reality that is an absolute lie.
     
Topic Status:
Not open for further replies.


Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...


Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.