also @ TechSpot: Google warns users infected with DNSChanger malware, provides help

Xbox Live bans prompt class action lawsuit

By

On November 20, 2009, 11:15 AM EST

Looks like the recent wave of Xbox Live bans -- in which as many as one million users were cut off from the service -- is ready to evolve into a into a full on legal showdown. A Texas-based law firm by the name of AbingtonIP is reportedly organizing a class-action suit claiming Microsoft timed the bans to extract the maximum amount of money out of customers.

According to AbingtonIP, this "convenient" timing may have resulted in more Xbox Live subscription revenues for Microsoft than it would have if the console bans had taken place at some point before the release of Halo 3: ODST and Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2. The company is also said to have earned plenty of game sales revenue from these two titles before dropping the axe on infringing users.

Microsoft for its part says the bans were made to combat piracy and support safer and more secure gameplay, though the law firm contends that it also locked out users who had modified their Xboxes for reasons other than piracy -- which they admit is "arguably" against the terms of service.

AbingtonIP is recruiting plaintiffs through its website and looking for people who have had their Xbox banned from Xbox Live without a refund for their remaining subscription. What's your take on the issue, do they make a convincing case, or is this just a shady attempt to profit at Microsoft's expense?

Related Stories

No tags on this story

User Comments (57)

Post a comment
RealXboxMaster
on November 24, 2009
8:57 AM

I totally agree with guest. Nice post

Reply

Guest
on November 24, 2009
9:55 AM

I have had 3 XBox consoles which died from the blinking red ring of death. I am by no means a MS cheerleader. I was considering a modded box out of spite. In 07 I simply tossed the first console in the trash, "I didn't know any better". In 08 purchased #2 from a pawn shop, it lasted about 6mths. I took it out to a friend's ranch and we used it for target practice, that was fun. In 08 I tried to fix console #3 that was a gift from a friend, it was sent back unprepared stating, you are sh^$ out of luck because they could tell that the console had been opened. After talking to customer service, I found out that they were trying to detour the use of modded chips and cheats back then. I explained that I was neither and all I wanted was for my dam xbox to work. If their is anyone who has a claim against MS I would like to think it was me. After COD, COD2, Halo, and GW2 I would have to state that a lower intellect finding ways to cheat online and get the upper hand over someone playing by the rules is classic American. After playing against some of the vermin online in COD, I for one am asking for more regulation. I wouldn't even bother to contact MS if I had lost a box to the ban. Cry babies! Ha, Ha, I'm laughing at u everyday!

Reply

clyde94
on November 24, 2009
10:09 AM

The law firm is out to make some money at Microsoft's expense. The people using a modified xbox did it to play games without paying for them and they knew they where breaking the terms of service by modifying their box.They have not been blacklisted their console has been banned so go buy a new console play by the rules and quit your whining.

Reply

yangly18
on November 25, 2009
8:03 AM

I believe it is the users faults for going against the xbox agreement policy. Although the vast majority of users have never modded their systems in any way, it is the minority of people that caused this. Think about how many people play xbox online, I'm sure we won't be missing any of these players.

Reply

Guest
on November 25, 2009
9:31 AM

yes they do BUT look at my case i bought a used 360 and had no idea it was modded if it actually is...i have never played a burned game myself .If microsoft did this they should do it right instead of just assuming everyone with this system actually did something at least offer a way to verify or talk to people about it....they wont even talk to you.....i personally think they are handling it very shitty i own 3 xboxs and this elite is the only used console i have all the others are new purchases but now i have decided to have every single 360 i own modded and download and burn every game i can....they have pushed me over the limit

Reply

yangly18
on November 25, 2009
9:36 AM

well, your predicament is a different one though. Hopefully they are actually looking at emails that people send them, and in your case they should look into it. If you payed for it online, it is easily trackable, and they should replace yours.

Reply

Guest
on December 15, 2009
2:18 PM

I saw an earlier post about banning crippling the hard drive memory units etc after being banned. This is not true, after obtaining a new console you will have to recover your gamer tag and reassign your drm to your new console. After you do that the only thing you lose is any progress you made post ban.

Reply

Browse more commented news

Post a new comment

Guest user

To post as an anonymous
user click here
.

Members

If you are a TechSpot member,
please login first.


By signing up you gain complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of computer and technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Post messages, get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.

Subscribe to TechSpot

Get free exclusive content, learn about new features and tech breaking news.