French court convicts first internet user over Hadopi anti-piracy law

By Lee Kaelin on September 14, 2012, 10:30 AM

A French court has ordered a man to pay €150 for breaking the country’s controversial three-strike anti-piracy law, Hadopi, despite his soon to be ex-wife testifying under oath that she was responsible for downloading the two pirated songs in question.

Alain Prevost, a 40-year-old man from a small village in a rural area of eastern France must pay the €150 ($195) fine after his wife downloaded two Rihanna tracks. He chose to represent himself in court and based his defense on the fact his wife was responsible. However, in doing so he ended up incriminating himself by admitting he had known what was going on and had done nothing to prevent it. The prosecution is required to prove a person is guilty of downloading the infringing material, but Prevost handed them all the evidence they required to get a conviction.

Jérémie Zimmerman of the French digital rights group La Quadrature du Net condemned the verdict. “This is pure harassment and intimidation of this poor chap who doesn’t even know what happened to him, and shows the absurdity of the whole scheme […] Actually, Hadopi cases are completely empty of any evidence, with only IP addresses collected by private companies that no judge could ever accept as valid,” he said in an emailed statement to Ars Technica.

The law has proven unpopular in France following its 2009 introduction during President Nicolas Sarkozy’s tenure. He is a strong supporter of the legislation, though rather interestingly, his wife is a popular recording artist, which has led some to question whether she influenced his views.

The new government under President Francois Hollande has indicated that Hadopi may well be withdrawn. As it stands currently, those downloading pirated material are given three warnings before they face prosecution. Hadopi argues it gives those infringing plenty of time to mend their ways.

So far, Hadopi has identified over three million IP addresses they say are responsible for downloading copyrighted material, according to Terry Hart on his blog, Copyhype. “Of those, it sent out 1.15 million initial warnings. 102,854 users received a second warning. Of these, 340 received a third warning.”

Only 30 internet users ignored the third warning, yet Hadopi is only taking 14 of those to court. Prevost’s ruling is the first of those 14 due before the court.

User Comments: 7

Got something to say? Post a comment
hitech0101 said:

Reminds me of 'Alan' from two and a half men where he always gets screwed with no fault of his.

There was a article sometime back stating people stopped pricacy after one or two strikes,

I think they used up thier strikes and then found ways to not get caught.

Adhmuz Adhmuz, TechSpot Paladin, said:

Wait, how does two songs equal 3 warnings? Or do they just ignore the material that was downloaded in the first 3 strikes and prosecute in regards to the 4th instance? This whole thing just smells of corruption and bureaucratic non sense.

Tygerstrike said:


It was prolly after their third strike. To you it smells. But the ppl in power call it theft. The ppl who make the laws call it theft. The ppl who make the products being pirated call it theft. Its pretty hard to fight the system of laws by commiting lawlessness. The only way this changes is if ppl WORK towards that goal.

In France they gave the individual 3 chances to stop. They didnt and got busted. End of story.

TJGeezer said:

That's about $100 per Rihanna song, probably available at 99 cents thru iTunes. I wonder how much of that $200 will make its way past the lawyers and into Rihanna's pockets. I recall reading that in the U.K. every bit of a huge fine would go to the lawyers. Nice racket.

h4expo said:


dont you mean "le sigh"?

otester said:

Should have got a VPN after 1st warning.

Load all comments...

Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.