Bitcoin mining facility sued over noise pollution in Texas

Alfonso Maruccia

Posts: 1,707   +500
Staff
Facepalm: Bitcoin mining has long been criticized for consuming excessive amounts of electricity while offering minimal financial benefits to society. However, cryptocurrency mining can also have negative impacts on public health, as a group of citizens in Texas recently discovered through a lawsuit.

A mining facility operated by Marathon Digital near Granbury, Texas, has been generating excessive noise, prompting a group of residents to organize and sue the company in an effort to reclaim their peace and quiet. The group, called Citizens Concerned About Wolf Hollow, is urging MD to stop using CPUs and GPUs to convert electricity into cryptocurrency, as the noise from the facility's cooling systems is causing serious health issues for nearby residents.

The group, represented by the non-profit environmental law firm Earthjustice, is seeking a permanent injunction against MD's facility unless it can reduce its noise pollution. Marathon Digital's 300-megawatt mining facility is located alongside the Wolf Hollow II gas power plant. The company is even considering expanding the plant, which would enable it to mine more Bitcoin but also release an additional 760,000 tons of greenhouse gas emissions (CO2) annually.

Granbury residents have opposed the expansion plan, as the existing plant already generates excessive noise, especially at night. Marathon uses a combination of liquid immersion and fans to cool its 20,000 computing units, but nearby residents report that the fans produce a constant low hum that can be heard throughout the neighborhood.

Earthjustice lawyers reported that more than two dozen individuals have suffered direct health issues due to noise pollution from the plant. Symptoms include vertigo, hearing loss, migraines, fatigue, anxiety, and tinnitus. Earthjustice senior attorney Rodrigo Cantú emphasized that being deprived of proper sleep or having to endure constant background noise can have an "unreasonable" impact on overall health.

Marathon Digital, however, disputed the residents' claims. The company stated that 30 percent of its computing units have already been converted to liquid immersion cooling, with plans to reach 50 percent by the end of the year. MD asserted that the facility's noise levels are within normal operating ranges and that the alleged health problems caused by the fans have no scientific basis.

Texas is home to numerous cryptocurrency mining operations, thanks to its low taxes, available land, and minimal regulations. While the rise of generative AI has somewhat overshadowed Bitcoin, the virtual currency can still turn a profit – if enough energy is used.

An upcoming HBO documentary is expected to reveal the true identity of Satoshi Nakamoto, the mysterious figure who developed Bitcoin technology in 2008.

Permalink to story:

 
Assuming it is actually nosie and can be heard form afar, what kind of cooling devices are they using?
Jet engines converted into coolers? One jet engine = 1 million 120 2000rpm fans.
 
Regardless of your opinions on crypto, this is just ridiculous. The same type of whining used by neighborhood karens to get racetracks, drag-strips, and car clubs shut down across the country, only to whine when the kids went street racing.
 
Regardless of your opinions on crypto, this is just ridiculous. The same type of whining used by neighborhood karens to get racetracks, drag-strips, and car clubs shut down across the country, only to whine when the kids went street racing.
The worse thing about race tracks is when they build neighborhoods around them and the people who move next to them complain about the noise.

Like, they knew the race track was there before buying the house. And the developers still want 500k for a cardboard box.
 
Regardless of your opinions on crypto, this is just ridiculous. The same type of whining used by neighborhood karens to get racetracks, drag-strips, and car clubs shut down across the country, only to whine when the kids went street racing.
Well come one let's be realistic here. We can either look at one of two ways. The first is a "who shot first" situation. If people move to a place in hopes of achieving peace and quiet and some company barges in making a bunch of noise then sure, get the noise out. It wasn't there when I got here so I don't want it here. It's a logical viewpoint.

The other way to look at it is like this, in my opinion. I've seen many bitcoin farms. I've heard many bitcoin farms. It's not hard to keep them quiet enough to prevent noise from literally flooding neigborhoods. Really not hard so idk what this company is doing but they're definitely doing it wrong lol and because of that, they need to shut up either by isolating the noise better or simply going away. They're an unnecessary vermin that doesn't need to be making such racket. Mining bitcoin isn't productive to society so there's no reason to tolerate any of the literal noise that comes with it.

It's called disturbing the peace. Banging on a wall with a shovel isn't illegal but it's annoying enough that the police can arrest you if enough people cry about it and you don't stop.
 
I have to admit when I saw the headline, I wondered if an April Fools day story was published by accident.
Its probably the fans venting air out of the building and it can drive you mad. I also have to deal with excessive noise where I live sometimes, but from a different cause - home alarms.
 
I work at the powerplant next to the bitcoin mine. Not gonna lie it's loud af. You can hear it from a few miles off. The plant makes noise sure, but you can't hear us running from 4 miles away.
 
Why are the pictures of the power plant instead of the bitcoin mine? It's not like we are affiliated with them in anyway or form. We may make noise but not to the levels they do.
 
I have to admit when I saw the headline, I wondered if an April Fools day story was published by accident.
When considering that 300 MW is used in this "mining facility," removing the waste heat is no small task, and no one can change the laws of physics to make the heat exchange equation somehow different.. 300 MW is not just a singular PC somewhere with excessive fan whine.

This makes me think the "mining facility" is being run by a bunch of dolts seeking Ambrosia that they will never find.
 
What people tend to forget is a lot of older people are susceptible to low frequency noise pollution that these fans will be causing I can hear an earthquake coming a few seconds before it gets here because I can hear the low frequency rumble it makes as it's moving towards my house. as you get older your hearing changes you hear low frequencies better than higher ones
 
The noise problem is very small compared to this issue. "Texan Bitcoin miners profit by using less electricity; advocates say all Texans should get the same chance

Bitcoin miner Riot Platforms made headlines over the summer for making millions by selling pre-purchased power back to the grid. The news highlighted how the grid can benefit businesses more than consumers. " https://www.texastribune.org/2024/01/03/texas-bitcoin-profit-electricity/
 
When considering that 300 MW is used in this "mining facility," removing the waste heat is no small task, and no one can change the laws of physics to make the heat exchange equation somehow different.. 300 MW is not just a singular PC somewhere with excessive fan whine.

This makes me think the "mining facility" is being run by a bunch of dolts seeking Ambrosia that they will never find.
To be honest, I always thought a "mining facility" was a bunch of computers and dozens to maybe a few hundred GPUs in someone's garage or maybe rental space. I did not know it could be this big.
That's why I thought the headline was a gag or mistake.
 
Back