Yhe it the true Rocky, I have 4790K and since I buyed it new in 2014 still no problems, but like you I have it on distilled loop too and some reasonable OC (44/45). and what you say about the power curve on the new processors I think they made a left turn and too highly engineered modern processors to run on 90 C, so I think what you did with voltage you probably tried to keep it around 60 C and because the processors are not designed to run like that they loosed too mutch performance 
if I will be buying a new processor I should remember I am going to loose many mhz if I try to keep them in reasonable temperatures
if I will be buying a new processor I should remember I am going to loose many mhz if I try to keep them in reasonable temperatures