Well sorry i hit a nerve over HL2 and that you were feeling bitter over it. I said all I have to say in that old post, but really taking those points it made i defy anyone to argue that they are wrong. I just ask this, if you played the first one all the way through and enjoyed it (I loved it), did you feel the second one was better? There is a lower variety of enemies and weapons, far less uber enemies to leg it from in fear, you have vehicles but cant drive combine vehicles (not encountering moving combine land vehicles on the coast section is an inexcusable wasted opportunity) and the king of all complaints: not finding out anymore about the G-man. "wake up and smell the ashes" was a great line by the way, but after 5 years between first and second games i was itching to know who this guy really was and facing him in a showdown, which didnt happen. Some real info at the very least would have been nice.
On the enemies AI, well they are not as effective as in the first game, its not that they were great shots and neither should they have been or ever should be as that makes it too hard, but they would try and flush you out with grenades as soon as you hit cover for any length of time. That just gave the illusion of intelligence and added to the experience enormously in my mind. And finally we should have seen more of Black Mesa. That would have been interesting for those who liked the first one. Its as much of the story, surely, as Gordon, the G-man and yes Barney too
On having extra rooms and areas with nothing in, umm yeah it would seem like a waste of time, but it would add to the feeling of being in a real environment. To know its there is better than to know its not and your stuck running through a narrow path.
The title of the post refers to the combat of Oblivion. Well, maybe not that itself, just the way people move looks pretty unrealistic, like theyre floating almost? After playing Battlefield 2 ive been a bit spoilt perhaps in that respect, the way people run and stuff looks almost real. I havent got anything negative to say for Oblivion really (why would I its got total FREEDOM!!!), its not my kind of game thats all, I dont go in for wizards and dungeons and stuff. I did by it but on a whim to see how it would run on my pc, cos i heard its demanding. Pretty dum I know! ...but my flatmate gets alot of fun out of it
This thread is mega old, and my opinion of HL2 softened a bit in the mean time. I bought episode 1 and even quite liked it! but not enough to play it through more than twice. I'll probably buy Episode 2 as well, cos im still curious as to where the stories going and it will play pretty good to no doubt.
Sorry one more thing, I must own up and say when i bought the game I had a (mighty) Athlon XP 1700+ 512mb ram 34gb HD, soo the loading times were a major problem, teamed with an awesome ATI Radeon 7000 64mb. (no Transform and light so low settings on everything and absolutely no aa and af) Even then i was impressed by how good it looked and how well it all ran on my cacky machine. Better graphics and lower loading times that i would have had with a better pc would have raised my opinion of HL2, but not enough to stop me writing what i did all those years ago. I absolutely did not play it on easy.
Cheers!